Hi PlaidMan,
I prefer using Permatex Aviation Sealant for the oil pan. For me it seems to be a bit thicker than Hylomar and I feel that it will seal the pan gasket a bit better. I also get my pan gaskets from NAPA. They offer a better gasket made by Victor Rein (South Africa) that is slightly thicker than most of the LBC vendors. Also, are you using flat washers as well as split lock washers with each bolt? The trick to using Aviation sealant is to apply it liberally to both sides of the gasket and let it set up at least 1/2 hour before laying it in place. Of course, all mating surfaces should be spotless clean and dry before sealing. I never reuse an old paper gasket. And, torque well but don't absolutely crush the gasket, you will be distorting the pan as well.
Good luck.
Where in Louisiana are you?
Bill