• Hey there Guest!
    If you enjoy BCF and find our forum a useful resource, if you appreciate not having ads pop up all over the place and you want to ensure we can stay online - Please consider supporting with an "optional" low-cost annual subscription.
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this UGLY banner)
Tips
Tips

Strange battery charger behavior

coldplugs

Darth Vader
Platinum
Country flag
Offline
I've had an interesting experience over the past couple days with a battery charger. I rent garage space from a neighbor for winter storage and needed to charge a six volt battery over there. I brought a small DieHard charger/maintainer over and hooked it up. The charger has three indicators - “Charging”, “Battery Charged”, and “Battery Fault”. The fault light means that the connections are reversed or there's a short.

Normally, the Charging light glows for a while, then the Charged light goes on, and shortly afterwards the Charging light goes off.

In this case, the Charging light was flickering rapidly and the Charged light was lit. The Fault light was off. I knew that the battery was dead as a doornail since it showed about 0.5 volts on the meter. I tried this numerous times with the battery connected (to the car) and, later, with it removed from the car.

I brought the charger back home and tried it here, and it worked fine.

I finally brought the battery to my shop, figuring I needed a replacement. Just for the heck of it, I tried hooking the charger up again and this time it worked fine. So the only obvious variable here is the neighbor's electrical supply.

They have a box in their circuit that instantaneously fires up an emergency generator if the power fails – I don't know how it works but it produces a loud hum under normal conditions. I don't know if it affects the quality of their power. I do know that they can run computers etc with no problems.

The battery is now charged so I'm more curious than anything else. Does anyone have any ideas on why this would happen?
 

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
What does your charger do when connected to a somewhat sulphated battery?

The flickering 'Charging' light sounds suspicious to me, since when you start charging a sulphated battery, the voltage goes to "fully charged" almost instantly. My theory is that each flicker was putting just a tiny amount of charge into the battery, and that combined with the jostling and shaking as the battery was brought to your shop was enough to break through and let it charge normally. The 0.5v would also indicate that at least some level of suphating was present.

Just a WAG, though. Seems unlikely to me that their UPS system pollutes the power enough to affect a battery charger; but I guess it's possible. Modern computers are actually pretty rugged when it comes to noise & spikes on the hot wire; what they hate (if anything) is noise & spikes between neutral and ground.
 
OP
coldplugs

coldplugs

Darth Vader
Platinum
Country flag
Offline
I think you're on to something. Although I've never had a battery recover due to shaking it up a bit, it's certainly possible. I brought it to my place in a small cart behind a lawn tractor over a dirt road and a field so it got shook up pretty good.

I agree that their UPS isn't the likely culprit.

Thanks for the response.
 

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
coldplugs said:
Although I've never had a battery recover due to shaking it up a bit,
Long time ago, a friend and I were out in the middle of nowhere trying to start a TR3A that I had just bought. It didn't want to run, and we were using my Oldsmobile as a power source to jump it. Temps were below freezing, and when we finally got tired of standing around in the snow, we hopped in the Olds to head home. But, the Olds' battery didn't have enough oomph left to turn over the 425ci V8!

At my friend's suggestion, we took the battery loose and shook it pretty thoroughly. I can't explain why, but after that treatment the engine cranked and we went home. Nothing particularly wrong with the battery, it wasn't low on electrolyte or anything like that. It continued to work fine at least until the next winter.
 

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
Which is one definition of uninterruptible power supply.

But that wouldn't explain the loud hum.
 

1965_MGB

Jedi Warrior
Offline
That is kind of strange, but it could be that the generator is throwing something other than 60hz. I have seen issues here in S. Fl. with people running generators and getting some weird thing happening with refrigerators and such.

Just a thought.
 
OP
coldplugs

coldplugs

Darth Vader
Platinum
Country flag
Offline
Just to close this out...

I was able to charge the battery at my place and it held a charge. I tried at the neighbors again today and everything looked fine. The buzzing UPS was a red herring. The fault was most likely with the battery as TR3driver suggested.

Lights work, starter spins, all is well in 6v land.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
J TR4/4A Strange Problem Fitting Inner Fender Triumph 18
E TR6 Strange Steering Rack Cap Triumph 3
Vargus TR2/3/3A Strange dents Triumph 19
nicko Strange Engine Noise Austin Healey 7
jlaird MGB Strange daily question. MG 10
C MGB strange?? MG 3
J TR2/3/3A such strange thread on gear shift knob Triumph 12
7 Strange A/C - radio problem Other Cars 7
S TR2/3/3A Strange part Triumph 3
steveg Strange gasket pieces Austin Healey 5
steveg Strange Oil Leak Austin Healey 7
D TR2/3/3A Strange hole! Triumph 5
SherpaPilot Strange Noise While Cornering in TR6 Racing 3
Jim_Gruber Strange noises - Bad U Joint perhaps? Spridgets 10
Michael Oritt Strange debris found in sump Austin Healey 19
F TR2/3/3A Strange Loud Noise Triumph 11
C Strange...can won't start and then magically ressurects Austin Healey 16
bighealeysource Strange problem with throttle staying open Austin Healey 6
D TR2/3/3A Strange Transmission Issue Triumph 9
Rhodyspit75 Strange windshield washers Spridgets 0
tahoe healey strange OD question. Austin Healey 9
andrea Very strange austin healey 3.9 Austin Healey 5
M Strange Healey Tach Austin Healey 9
Rut Strange occurance! Spridgets 19
aeronca65t Big Healey-strange wheels Austin Healey 12
bighealeysource Okay, here's one with a strange noise from the engine Austin Healey 7
J TR2/3/3A Strange fiberboard panel behind rear seat in TR3 Triumph 10
J TR4/4A Strange question that may involve the coil- Triumph 13
jlaird Todays strange question Spridgets 6
JPSmit What is that strange grinding sound in the distance? Spridgets 3
PAUL161 MGB Strange Reminder of a Missing Friend. MG 4
B Strange rear light Other British Cars 6
KVH Strange Sound Like Compressed Air Escaping Triumph 14
Bremer TR2/3/3A TR3A: Strange brake bleeding behaviour Triumph 4
B SU Carbs have strange vacuum fitting Triumph 17
Kleykamp TR2/3/3A Strange TR3 side curtains ??? Triumph 13
HAN8L1965 Strange event ? Spridgets 6
T strange litter Triumph 5
aeronca65t Strange and interesting MGs MG 3
PAUL161 Strange 5 Speed Conversion - Will it Work? MG 41
W Strange occurence Spridgets 5
P Strange clunking noise Triumph 20
bugedd Strange trans noise Spridgets 7
Musicman Strange Clicky/Tappy Sound Triumph 6
SilentUnicorn Strange things British Motorbikes 4
Bremer Strange, but interesting... factory blunders? Triumph 8
M another strange bugeye on ebay Spridgets 12
JAV strange noise Austin Healey 4
J Strange electric problem. Jaguar 11
racingenglishcars This is a strange one! Spridgets 9

Similar threads

Top