Moss has genuine Hylomar (not the 'HPF' stuff that Permatex sold under license). Permatex actually stopped making Hylomar for awhile, but I see they now have it listed on the website as "back by popular demand", so perhaps it will start finding it's way into stores soon.
But for an oil pump, I'm not convinced it's worth the extra effort. Almost anything (except silicone RTV) will work fine : Permatex #3, Gasgacinch, Indian Head, etc. In fact I'd feel quite confident using nothing at all, since small drips will just fall back into the pan instead of on the ground.