Looking similar does not make the radiator perform similar. There are a multitude of different cores that could be used in these. The gauge of aluminum, the type of connection between the core and the tank, the tank design, the type of radiator cap, drain plug, temp fitting, and general quality control.
The Serick unit is obviously a bespoke item and no doubt they would stand behind their work. I'm guessing wizard cooling would also stand behind their work. An ebay special is just that and nothing more. I have no idea about "bugeye guy" radiator. If I had to guess I would say that he is selling the same radiator that you see on ebay that he has already drilled and filed to fit. But I'm just guessing.