• Hey there Guest!
    If you enjoy BCF and find our forum a useful resource, if you appreciate not having ads pop up all over the place and you want to ensure we can stay online - Please consider supporting with an "optional" low-cost annual subscription.
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this UGLY banner)
Tips
Tips

What's with all the Engine Rebuild Failures?

Michael Oritt

Yoda
Gold
Country flag
Online
While I have not yet had the need to remove, disassemble and major my Healey's engine since its last rebuild about 50K miles ago I have stood at the elbow of a local trusted mechanic while we disassembled and rebuilt the engines of both Elvas, the Courier being powered by an OHV MGA 1600 and the MK IV sportsracer powered by a SOHC Coventry Climax FWB 1490.

In both cases I assisted the mechanic by passing parts and tools to him as he proceeded to disassemble the engines, inspecting, measuring, assessing and sometimes photographing the various components preparatory to ordering necessary replacement parts and having whatever work done to the head, block, etc. (including outside machine shop work) before we proceeded to reassembly.

Having witnessed the teardown/reassembly of the MGA engine thrice and the Climax engine once I am happy to say that at this point I am NOT presently qualified to perform the mechanic's work. In all cases we proceeded according to factory manuals but it quickly became clear to me that he had knowledge of potential pitfalls, shortcuts, "tricks of the trade", etc. he had gained by having rebuilt many and diverse engines of all types over 40 years and I quickly understood that I would likely have early on come up against a problem I was not equipped to solve and/or made a mistake because all of the nuanced skills necessary are not spelled out in the manuals but rather are assumed to be within the mechanic's knowledge base.

Bottomline I am a result-oriented person and am fortunate that I can afford the services of someone who knows his way through the process of achieving the results I desire. I try to know my limitations and realize that while I am learning I am not yet there.
 
D

Deleted member 21878

Guest
Guest
Offline
if cleanliness is #1, and i believe it is. 2nd is have a good place to do the work. a clean place with controlled temperature and humidity. keeps the parts from surface rust and getting dirty again while they wait for you to get them all installed. i would not do this again without having a room set up. in fact i think that is going to be my next project.

Also agree with MO on the manual not having the details for novices. That is why these forums are so great. this is my 5th car of one brand or another (post internet) and each one i end up doing a little more of the work. would not have happened without the help.
 

Mike Tobin

Freshman Member
Country flag
Offline
I'll let y'all know when I finally get it started. Now that the weather's warmed up and the frustration level is back down it's safe to start working again. Back to the timing chain so pulling the radiator (again) is the next step. But that will allow me to get a shroud soldered on - not on the car when I got it long ago and far away.

At least this makes me feel better - I'm not alone.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
sim oil pressure gage bad or engine needs rebuild It starts our cold at 60 psi but when warm it down to 10 psi Spridgets 21
KVH General Tech More Engine Rebuild Questions Triumph 15
BobHaskell Mini Cooper 1275 engine rebuild British Motor Corp 9
J Engine rebuild Austin Healey 4
classicmechanic Amazon engine rebuild pics Other Cars 6
M 948 Engine Rebuild Question Spridgets 0
M engine stutter of rebuild BT7 engine [tri-carb] above 2500 rpm Austin Healey 27
60TR3A Cost to Rebuild a Healey 3000 Engine [And Recommendations About Who to Do It] Austin Healey 14
M E Type 4.2 engine rebuild Jaguar 4
Got_All_4 TR6 TR6 engine rebuild. Too tight? Triumph 23
Healey Nut Engine rebuild Austin Healey 17
Got_All_4 TR6 What engine bearings to use in my rebuild? Triumph 9
R BT7 engine gallery plug replacement during rebuild Austin Healey 3
T How to add a bit more realiability/endurance to a stock 1275 engine rebuild? Spridgets 9
G Failure on Initial Engine Start After Rebuild Austin Healey 176
HighAltitudeTR3 TR2/3/3A Any feedback on this? Rimmer Bros engine rebuild Triumph 6
KVH General Tech Engine Rebuild: Failed at Cam Break-in Triumph 11
simon1966 A few shots from the 100 engine rebuild Austin Healey 18
JimLaney Engine rebuild - how critical is rust? Spridgets 3
G TR4/4A A couple of engine rebuild questions... Triumph 8
N Engine rebuild ??? Spridgets 4
Csarneson BN4 Engine Rebuild Questions Austin Healey 8
Csarneson Engine Rebuild Disaster - Cylinder Crack Austin Healey 20
D Engine rebuild questions. Austin Healey 18
M Need Advice On 948 Engine Rebuild Spridgets 7
W TR2/3/3A Novice TR3 Engine Rebuild Triumph 47
W TR2/3/3A Engine rebuild - looking for preliminary advice Triumph 7
T TR4/4A What is trickiest part of engine rebuild? Triumph 15
D MGB 1963 MGB engine rebuild MG 4
H Off Topic Nifty Time-Lapse Video of Spitfire Engine Rebuild Triumph 2
gbtr6 TR6 Engine Rebuild kit Triumph 12
gbtr6 TR6 TR 6 Engine rebuild/freshen Triumph 21
Rut TR4/4A Performance engine rebuild Triumph 3
me61ic Timelapse '63 BJ7 engine rebuild Austin Healey 5
Rut MGB Engine rebuild, then... MG 29
mcmillal TR4/4A Engine / Transmission Rebuild Triumph 1
JPSmit Engine Rebuild question Restoration & Tools 10
S TR2/3/3A Engine rebuild Triumph 9
TexasSprite Engine Rebuild Video Spridgets 1
Healey Nut Engine rebuild Austin Healey 9
mt10flyer TR2/3/3A 1959 TR3 engine rebuild problems Triumph 14
PatGalvin The fun just won't stop [engine rebuild questions] Triumph 53
Tim Tucker TR4/4A TR4 Engine rebuild Triumph 4
J TR4/4A Engine rebuild on a TR4 Triumph 19
MGTF1250Dave XPAG Engine Rebuild MG 0
B Engine Rebuild MG 1
Johnny Spitfire How to rebuild a Spitfire 4 cyl engine in 45 sec. Triumph 2
Sarastro Here's the REAL way to rebuild a Triumph engine! Triumph 1
luke44 Spitfire Spitfire Engine Rebuild- Great Video Triumph 2
HealeyRick 1500 Engine Rebuild Made Easy Spridgets 5

Similar threads

Top