I think so as well, the shift forks are not frozen the gears turn smoothly under them. Think it is in fourth.
The rods that the shift forks ride on are solid as a rock. All else through out the transmission moves free and easy, smoothly, etc.
Have bp blaster in the detent holes, springs came out with black tar kinda stuff, cleaned good with carb cleaner and filled with blaster. This may take awile but I am sort of conveienced that is where the problem lies as well. I see nothing else that could cause the problem.
Someone please jump in if you think I have this scoped out incorrectly. Damb those gears are nice, as is everything in there, I would swear that all is new.
Jack