Oh, my... I must confess I never saw any attraction in any of VW based kits, or in very few of the others.
The "Jamaican" from years ago looked nice enough, though, and some of the modern kits that don't try to be something they're not seem decent but most replicars don't seem to me to try very hard...
Some of the replicas that try to be accurate are appealing- like Westfield's Lotus XI replica or the SS-100 Jaguar.