I would never assume just because I paid the most for something, I got the most, in other words, just because I paid a high premium, I had the best insurance. Being with Erie for about 20 yrs., I can say they have always been unbelievable. In fact, in 1987, my P/U truck caught on fire, and after talking to them, I didn't believe what they told me, and called back to verify that I was in fact going to get what they said I would, it was that good. And, they have always been hundreds cheaper than other companies. In fact, I don't know how many times, other companies have declined to give a quote when they found out you had Erie, as they knew they could not compete. However, don't even bother calling them about classic cars and motorcycles, as its not what they want to insure. Also, I believe Hagerty's is the best, and they are also inexpensive. That being said, not everyone will meet the qualifications for the better insurance companies best deals. The best prices go to those with the best driving history, and claim records. And, thats how our health insurance should be also, but, that's another story.