Had the same problem with mine. I made a new piece. I drilled the spot welds holding in the old one. Do it carefully, as you want it as much as possible to be in one piece, as this will be the template for the new one. To tell you the truth, I don't remember if I drilled from the door side or the fender side. I'll look when I get home tonight. I should be able to tell. Anyway, bend that pulled out section back into place as best you can. After it's out, wrap a piece of paper over the top over the broken piece and cut and trim it so it fits perfectly. This will be the template for the new piece. Now you can trace it onto a piece of metal the same thickness that you can get a Home Depot etc. I cut out the new piece SLIGHTY larger so I could make any minor adjustments after it was bent inot shape. The bending is the trickiest part, but not impossible. I started with the middle bend. I used a small drill bit to wrap it around so it wouldn't crease. I had to do some minor trimming to get it into the hole, but it worked out pretty good. When I get home tonight, I'll take some pics of the old and new.