• Hi Guest!
    You can help ensure that British Car Forum (BCF) continues to provide a great place to engage in the British car hobby! If you find BCF a beneficial community, please consider supporting our efforts with a subscription.

    There are some perks with a member upgrade!
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this gawd-aweful banner
Tips
Tips

A Bugeye tale .....

lewmac

Senior Member
Offline
I have a great story to share. Well, certainly an interesting tale ….


I have this Bugeye nicknamed "Greeny" (for obvious reasons) that I purchased on eBay in November 2013 from a guy in Florida who told me at the time that he had a clear title for the car. After the car arrived from Florida with no title or Bill of Sale, the stories started to flow. Title was at first held up in probate hearing (unfortunately the previous owner had passed away), potentially making the sale of the car illegal. Then the title was on its way, his business partner was going to South Carolina to pick it up. Then the title was “lost” by previous owner, the deceased. Anyway, this shady character never supplied the title and the car had no VIN, BAE or engine number tags, so the title could not be traced. The only tag on the car was the Factory Commission or order number which is not a number recorded by BMC and is not traceable through Heritage Motor Company, so really of no use in Identifying the car. Sounds a bit suspicious right, like a stolen car stripped of all ID numbers ?


I filed a complaint with eBay and of course was quickly shunted to eBay Auction Insurance Agency. After 12 months of phone calls between them and the seller, without any real progress, they put me in contact with a very diligent and helpful guy at Florida DMV in Ft.Myers to investigate the seller and the dubious dealership name listed as 76 Group Motors. The seller had by accident – it was in the driver’s door pocket - sent me the previous Bill of Sale from when he purchased the car, so I had the name and address of the previous owner. The Bill of Sale listed the dealer as 76 Group Motors, which were apparently linked to Mid City Motors dealership in Ft.Myers. The seller then claimed he sold it as an individual, so DMV passed it over to Florida Highway Patrol for criminal investigation, since it is apparently illegal to sell a car in Florida without a title.


That was maybe 3 months ago, so I thought it was a dead end. So, following Illinois Secretary of State guidelines I purchased a Surety Bond and submitted it with a notarized Statement of Purchase to DMV in Illinois to obtain a title, using the AN530252 number listed on the previous Bill of Sale to identify the car. Illinois DMV sent the application back saying that I needed a Title to transfer or, a Law Enforcement Officer inspection to confirm the VIN # was correct and an appraisal by an Officer of a Car Club or a Licensed Dealer. So, no VIN tag, no chance for an Illinois title. What a hassle !


So, my only choice to get a title appeared to be to find a set of tags with a title, essentially buy another Bugeye body in need of restoration. How often does it happen, that when you really need a part or in this case, a bugeye body or a set of tags with title, that it appears on eBay ? Seems to happen to me frequently. Believe or not, within a week of receiving the letter from Jesse White, Secretary of State (Illinois DMV) a complete set of tags from a Bugeye appeared on eBay, with a title available as well. Purchased the tags & title, back in business.


Then about a week later, I get this call out of the blue from a Florida Highway Patrol Trooper in the Criminal and Fraud Investigation Unit in Ft.Myers, FL. The FHP Trooper that was assigned the case, by good fortune, has raced Healey's and other English sportscars, a real enthusiast. He also proved to be a really good detective ! In the space of a week, he had virtually solved the case and identified three possible VIN numbers for the car.


With the information I had gathered on previous owner (now deceased), he contacted the widow and she confirmed he had owned three Bugeyes when he lived in both NC and SC. She provided his full name and addresses for both states. We used the only tag on the vehicle - you know that useless non traceable number, the BMC factory order or commission # AN5 30252 - from the plate in the driver's door pocket to approximate build date as late 1959 or early 1960. The Trooper then requested an archive search in both NC and SC for 1959 and 1960 Bugeyes owned by the deceased.


When the respective DMVs conducted the archive searches for VINs matching his addresses, they came up with 3 VINs. One of these VINs was on a registered car titled in South Carolina. Of the other two, one had been titled in NC (likely my car) and the other had no record of being titled (hopefully the race car mentioned below).


After his death, these two cars were sold by the widow to the guy in Florida, who then sold them on eBay - a white race car with blue stripe that was sold to a guy in Vancouver (the Trooper had his name and has reached out to him also to see if that car had a VIN or BAE tag attached) and the Green car with wire wheels which I bought. Greeny also had an old NC rego windscreen sticker which indicated it had been registered in NC and may match a previous NC title on the car. NC DMV were supposed to search the archives for previous owners and get back to the Trooper.


I also informed the Trooper that the original color was Antique White, visible under the car, and red interior trim of which there are remnants remaining in the car. I suggested the only way to confirm the colors as a match to the VIN, and to obtain the BAE and engine numbers was to inquire with Heritage Motor Center in the UK for the car details. The Trooper sent on the following Monday a "criminal investigation" inquiry to HMC and overnight had a reply ! Turns out that both cars with the VINs we had were originally white with red trim, so no joy there, except that they were able to provide BAE and Engine numbers for both VINs at no charge.


So, the next information received was that the Vancouver owner came back and confirmed he had a 3rd different VIN to the two "possible" VINs, which again did not help our case.


Then, a breakthrough !


NC DMV sent the Trooper the microfiche of title records for the suspected VIN number dating back to 1975. The Trooper then contacted the next in line previous owner to the deceased – apparently the only surviving previous owner - to see if he could identify the car as his previous Bugeye. He had apparently sold the car in 1998 to the deceased owner. After email contact, I sent him a link to photos of Greeny and he was not only able to identify the car, but told us that he had the car painted green over the previous blue, which was visible under the bonnet and had painted the red seat covers black. He also identified the Union Jack bonnet stickers, factory wood rim steering wheel, early wire wheels with drum brake setup, the unusual rear tire mount bracket and was able to send photos of the car painted blue and then freshly painted green.


So, now I have a confirmed VIN, BAE and Engine number and should be able to get an Illinois title, with a law enforcement inspection and a value appraisal from a licensed dealer or car club officer. Only took 18 months and a very diligent Trooper to solve the case.


Here are the “identifying” early pics of the car and a current day pic. When I get the title, the car will be for sale !


Cheers
Lew
Greeny before paint.jpg

Greeny with fresh paint from Brian Brown.jpg

IMG_0039.jpg
 
Great story!

So, after all that, why are you selling?

If you care to have another go, I've got this MGB out back... :devilgrin:
 
Well, originally I purchased this car to export it, along with 5 others to Australia. No title, no export, and that boat has sailed a year ago !

I also have two other projects, a '60 Bugeye "keeper" and a Sebring fastback project based on a '68 MkIV Sprite, more than enough to keep me busy. Funds from Greeny will be used for the other projects.

Cheers
Lew




Great story!

So, after all that, why are you selling?

If you care to have another go, I've got this MGB out back... :devilgrin:
 
Isn't it illegal to buy a vin/trim tag and title for purposes of putting it on a different car other than the original.
 
I do not think it is illegal to buy a vin tag and title. I think it IS illegal to swap it onto another car and then register it.
 
Lew, how's about an update on the Sebring??

[I may be facing something similar on a Berkeley...owner now deceased]

Kurt.
 
Quite the tale. Such tales always make me nervous when dealing long distance for a car -- even though my luck has been good so far.
 
In response to anarchy99,

So if I bought the car body with the tags and then replaced the body with a new shell, would that be OK ? Interesting question .....
 
Hi Trevor,

Yes, perhaps. But from a differnet perspective, if I was to buy a new bugeye body shell from Frogeye spares to restore the car that the tags came from, is that any different ? The previous car body has been destroyed, so the title and tags should be able to used on a "restoration" or new car body, IMHO.

It's an interesting dilemma, one that has been documented many times with cars being re-bodied.

In any case, I now do not need to use the tags and title, but know of several other people who would like them .....

Cheers
Lew




I do not think it is illegal to buy a vin tag and title. I think it IS illegal to swap it onto another car and then register it.
 
Selling because I have 2 other projects, a Bugeye "keeper" and a Sebring Fastback replica based on a '68 Mk IV Sprite.
Cheers
Lew
 
Hi Kurt,

Good luck with the Berkley. What year is it based on ? Does it have any tags in the door hinge pockets ? Still with no title, it may be difficult.

The Sebring is progressing slowly. Underfloor restored, sealed and painted - French Blue - rear suspension restored, upgraded to urethane bushes and tube shocks, all reinstalled. Now working on engine bay to paint, so I can install front suspension. Just ordered a lowering kit for the front and a few other parts tonight. Need to get it back on wheels as we are moving to Chicago area in mid July.

Pretty much ready to bond body shell which is bolted in place, but will leave it until after we move.

Cheers
Lew





Lew, how's about an update on the Sebring??

[I may be facing something similar on a Berkeley...owner now deceased]

Kurt.
 
Interesting story... I'm amazed there was an investigator that gave a rip. Friend of mine had a car stolen out of a driveway and the local police gave a lecture about how they had better things to do than chase stolen cars...Call your insurance company was the basic jist of it.

Some states don't require titles for cars older than 25 years. Maine is one. They will not even look at a title if the car is 25 years or older. So.... My understanding is that states that do require titles have loopholes for cars coming from states that don't. Just FYI.

My personal suspicion is that a majority of AN5 Sprites do not wear the VIN they left the factory with. The screwed on VIN tag and the worthlessness of the car led to many a swap by the late 60's/early 70's. I don't think it was an evil, nefarious plot, rather just a practical reality. And one that continues...
 
Lew, the Berk is a 57 B90. The title mess is my own fault. i have one but it looks like a photo copy and my local DMV is suspect of it and I haven't taken the time to sort it out. The PO was literally on his death bed when i bought it and trying to simplify things for his wife. That and I was probably too anxious to get the car.

Kurt
 
Ah, I was thinking Arkley ! Just looked up the Berkeley, nice.

Good luck with that title.... sometimes depends on the person at the DMV !

Cheers
Lew


Lew, the Berk is a 57 B90. The title mess is my own fault. i have one but it looks like a photo copy and my local DMV is suspect of it and I haven't taken the time to sort it out. The PO was literally on his death bed when i bought it and trying to simplify things for his wife. That and I was probably too anxious to get the car.

Kurt
 
People have been doing it for years on other cars with trim tags and vin tags... 69 camaros come to mind. It's illegal because it's transforming one car into another car, a thief can just swap a few things from a stolen car with a salvaged or other car with tags from eBay and he's back in business. I realize on a lot of cars there are other vins on fenders etc but a lot of those could be ground down etc and if the story is good enough it will pass. My sprite doesn't have the vin it left the factory with, only the body tag. Works for me, I'd just dig into the legality of something before doing it.
 
I know of a Shelby mustang that isn't.....or is it. If the tags were swapped from a wrecked car plus all the item's that Shelby fitted, pretty much it's a Shelby. Very grey area but I can see why the law gets involved.

Kurt.
 
If anyone else is in this situation, maybe this guy could help you out. He posted this on the MG Experience Website

"I am the proud owner of the vin tag, the original embossed one, and the "pink slip" for a bugeye. Very early car number. The car is gone but if anyone needs title for a car that doesn't have one I can help you out."



https://www.mgexp.com/phorum/read.php?3,3000711
 
I have to say that I find this idea of affixing the number from one car to another troubling. I know it has been done many times, and will continue to be done, but it can't be right on a number of levels. Sorry to get Existential, but in my view the car is the car (it is the thing that exists, or not if it has been destroyed), and the number is just the label that authenticates it and places it in some kind of context, including production sequence and the date it came into existence. You can easily dismiss that idea as just a lot of hot air, but I'm certain that if you pass off, say, a 1960 Bugeye as an early production 1958 and you are found out, you'll be in a heap of trouble. Not super smart, either, as early production cars are different than later ones.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top