FWIW I picked up a reproduction original pump from TRF a few years back after the shaft broke on my original. Fits and works fine. I haven't kept track, but I've probably got 20K miles on it.
However, you need to be certain that the pulley is a tight fit on the shaft. If it will move easily with the nut removed, the fit is too loose and will eventually fail. (I had to replace the pulley too, the TRF replacement was a good fit. Don't forget the captive bolt, unless you've upgraded with a mounting stud.)
When we discussed rebuilding a few years back, it turned out that the original bearings were a funny size that was obsolete even when the cars were new. No one could find a current source. Has someone come up with a source of bearings that fit? Or is it still required to machine the housing and replace the shaft to use modern bearings?