• The Roadster Factory Recovery Fund - Friends, as you may have heard, The Roadster Factory, a respected British Car Parts business in PA, suffered a total loss in a fire on Christmas Day. Read about it, discuss or ask questions >> HERE. The Triumph Register of America is sponsoring a fund raiser to help TRF get back on their feet. If you can help, vist >> their GoFundMe page.
  • Hey there Guest!
    If you enjoy BCF and find our forum a useful resource, if you appreciate not having ads pop up all over the place and you want to ensure we can stay online - Please consider supporting with an "optional" low-cost annual subscription.
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this UGLY banner)
Tips
Tips

TR4/4A What kind of oil in overdrive gearbox?

shoopal

Jedi Trainee
Country flag
Offline
I found my overdrive problem thanks to Leo Ruof and John from Quantum Mechanics. Stuck cone clutch.
Now I am ordering the gaskets and seals to put it back together and I'm totally confused as to what kind of oil to use.
Leo (veteran of 300+ OD rebuilds) is adamant for SAE 20-30 as is the Laycock shop manual (PUBLICATION PART No. 502274). On the other hand the owners manual (p 16) and other sources are recommending GL4 80-90 wt gear oil.
What say you all?
 

Merlin63Tr4

Jedi Trainee
Country flag
Offline
Opinions/recommendations are all over the place as far as what is the “correct” oil for the overdrive gearboxes.

The TR4 owner’s manual says 90 weight GL4 gear oil.

Rebuilders call for everything from straight SAE 50 motor oil to SAE 10W-40, 20W-50 motor oil and so on.
If I remember correctly my brother's old MGB used SAE 30 motor oil.
My Volvo uses ATF (275K miles on that one).

On my TR4 I originally was using 80W-90 GL4 gear oil, I’m currently using Redline MT 90 GL4 gear oil.



M.
 
Last edited:

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
This topic has been endlessly debated, with no clear winners. The legend, as I heard it, is that Standard-Triumph changed their recommendation (to GL4) based on having too many warranty gearbox failures. The early TR2-3 owners manuals do specify either 30 weight or 50 weight motor oil (depending on outside temperature) but changed around 1958-60 to specifying GL4 gear oil (80 or 90 depending on outside temperature). Supposedly the extreme pressure additives help protect the layshaft bearings and thrust washers (which are a known weak spot in the TR2-6 gearbox).

Personally, I couldn't see any change in OD operation when I switched from running Valvoline VR1 20W50 to Redline MT-90 (which is a 75W90 GL4 gear oil). But it sure made a noticeable difference in how well the main gearbox shifted.

Worth noting, perhaps, that the oil "grades" (eg 30 weight or 90 weight) are deliberately different between gear oil and motor oil. It's tempting to think that 90 weight is 3 times as thick as 30 weight. But the MT-90 is roughly the same viscosity (at the same temperature) as 10W40 motor oil!
 

TomMull

Darth Vader
Silver
Country flag
Offline
Worth noting, perhaps, that the oil "grades" (eg 30 weight or 90 weight) are deliberately different between gear oil and motor oil. It's tempting to think that 90 weight is 3 times as thick as 30 weight. But the MT-90 is roughly the same viscosity (at the same temperature) as 10W40 motor oil!

You are right to point out this common misconception and your example does get the point across and probably needs no further comment. However, at the risk of muddling the point, it might be better to say that the weights would be very similar at operating temperature (high) since the 10W40 would be much less viscous when cold. This could be significant if we assume that many gearboxes run at a lower temperature than engines. Might be even better to compare multi viscosity gear oils with multi viscosity engine oils e.g. 75W90 roughly equivalent with 10W40.
Tom
 
Last edited:

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
You are right to point out this common misconception and your example does get the point across and probably needs no further comment. However, at the risk of muddling the point, it might be better to say that the weights would be very similar at operating temperature (high) since the 10W40 would be much less viscous when cold. This could be significant if we assume that many gearboxes run at a lower temperature than engines. Might be even better to compare multi viscosity gear oils with multi viscosity engine oils e.g. 75W90 roughly equivalent with 10W40.
Tom
Sorry I wasn't more specific, Tom. Redline MT-90 is, in fact, a 75W90 gear oil. Pretty much all synthetic oils wind up being "multi-weight" as they don't change viscosity as much over temperature as the "dinosaur juice" does.
https://www.redlineoil.com/product.aspx?pid=46

You are quite right, a straight 90 weight oil would be much thicker at lower temperatures, more comparable to a straight 40 (or 50) weight motor oil.

attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • Table_5_viscosity_comparison_chart.jpg
    Table_5_viscosity_comparison_chart.jpg
    69.8 KB · Views: 204
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
V Datsun gearbox: what kind of oil do you use? Spridgets 10
mylillooker Oil, ...how much? What kind? Spridgets 2
equiprx BUG EYE SPRITE, One of a kind print, Signed by the photographer Austin Healey Classifieds 0
JPSmit Kind of an engine question Spridgets 11
Sarastro TR4/4A What kind of wood and finish for the dashboard? Triumph 20
P TR2/3/3A Wheel hop of the unconventional kind Triumph 6
A TR6 be kind Triumph 5
T TR4/4A Yeah, I kind of bought another TR4. I wasn't looking - honest. Triumph 43
C The 1956 Jaguar XKSS was one of a kind Jaguar 10
K TR4/4A What kind of restoration? Triumph 15
B TR6 Does a 75 amp alternator require a wiring upgrade of any kind? Triumph 3
S TR6 It's alive! [kind of] Triumph 2
D T-Series Let's play "What kind of transmission does this go in?" MG 1
D What kind of paint.... Spridgets 55
Patrick67BJ8 Spark Plugs for '67 3000....what kind? Austin Healey 23
TR4nut My od probs, kind of like Toms! Triumph 14
JPSmit My kind of Rat Rod Other Cars 4
PC my kind of shooting brake Spotted 13
I What kind of grease do I need for wiper motor? Spridgets 5
smaceng What kind of car is this? Other Cars 8
V What kind of battery? Spridgets 6
I What kind of glue to use for ribbed bugeye panels? Spridgets 7
drooartz sorta kind ish maybe looking for a RHD Bugeye Spridgets 8
HealeyRick My Kind of Gal! Austin Healey 12
58Custom What kind of wheel is this on this Midget? Spridgets 2
tr6nitjulius Resto..of another kind! Triumph 4
aeronca65t A "GT"--what kind? Spotted 3
bighealeysource steering effort kind of jerky on new restoration Austin Healey 5
Tr3aguy What kind of Media? Triumph 4
T a new kind of transmission? Austin Healey 3
T Can you tell what kind of car this is Triumph 9
Dadandson What kind of thread is this??? Spridgets 13
regularman Its kind of cool when you google Spridgets 3
tomshobby TR4/4A TR4 help of a different kind. Triumph 9
O what kind of car is that?producer? Other British Cars 10
C Gorgeous and One-of-a-Kind AH100 [49 photos!] Austin Healey 2
B What Kind of Clutch Fluid? Spridgets 4
Baz What kind of sadist...... Spridgets 25
C What kind of roll bar is this? Spridgets 12
7 What kind of ignition system are you using? Triumph 39
J What kind of compound to use as wing2body sealing Triumph 6
Sherlock What kind of truck is this? Other Cars 10
toysrrus Hey; "Kind of Blue"!! Triumph 1
Luke_Healey How do I figure out what kind of brake fluid? Spridgets 24
spartan0199 What kind of cars do Healey owners drive? Austin Healey 63
H TR6 TR6 Up-date... she's running... kind of... Triumph 4
jlaird And now for a different kind of question Spridgets 14
roofman A new kind of Ebay scam? Triumph 18
J what kind of paint[s] should I use Triumph 7
jlaird Kind of cool but I am ready Spridgets 1

Similar threads

Top