Experienced the same problem when I installed my OD. The clamp might be slipping even though you tightened it aggressively. Over the years the clamp gets deformed and bottom and top half touch before a tight clamping action is made. Are the tabs on the clamp making contact with each other?
You can make the shaft larger or make the clamp smaller.
Two approaches, 1. wrap some aluminum tape, or a strip of beer can around the shaft then reinstall ....making the shaft larger.
Better, use a grinder to take off some material between the ears that the bolt passes through...this will allow for more "travel" and make the clamp smaller
Let us know what works