If your use is light and are not into aggressive driving, as was my profile, the primary characteristic I looked for in a tire was longevity and diameter (for clearing my Phase 1 resonators). Since it has often been stated that the rule of thumb for a tire's safety-longevity (before dry rot takes over) is 10 years, I decided to get the tire with the most recent manufacturing date, even if it costs a little more.
When I was looking for new tires, Kumho 165s were highly recommended and very reasonably priced at around $55 plus shipping, mounting, and balancing. However, the only available Kumho tires, in the size I wanted, were manufactured between 3 and 4 years prior. I opted for Vredesteins at a price of $112 (everything included) that just entered the country and were manufactured at around a month prior.
Although I like the look and performance of the Vredestein Classics, I still believe the Kumho's would have performed just as well for me.
Good luck,
Ray (64BJ8P1)