Trevor Jessie
Yoda
Offline
I'm not sure what to think about this product?
https://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/MG-Midget...#ht_4584wt_1100
https://cgi.ebay.com/ebaymotors/MG-Midget...#ht_4584wt_1100
Hi Guest!
smilie in place of the real @
Pretty Please - add it to our Events forum(s) and add to the calendar! >> Here's How << 
Bulk thermal conductivity is not the only factor, or even the most significant factor, in radiator performance.regularman said:...I would think it needs to be a bigger surface area. Aluminum does not conduct as good as copper or brass. ...
Yeah, I have seen some of the welding on the tanks parts of the aluminum radiators that looks like I did it at home. Most motorcycle radiators are aluminum and they work good as long as you take care of them but corrosion is crippling to them inside. They can't be soldered or worked on (I have tried with a tig freq unit) and I would feel better with copper or brass. I am old fashioned I guess. Most new cars got aluminum radiators with plastic tanks on the side, but I think its a cost savings rather than better quality. Looking over my brother's, I couldn't see that the core was any smaller. I know what you mean by smaller density of the tubes, some of those Mercedes heater cores were amazing for their size but they were copper. If they did that with aluminum that would be awesome but I have not seen a real smaller size in a car radiator.PC said:Bulk thermal conductivity is not the only factor, or even the most significant factor, in radiator performance.regularman said:...I would think it needs to be a bigger surface area. Aluminum does not conduct as good as copper or brass. ...
A higher conductivity material can flow less heat overall if there's a poorer connection path through it between the heat source and sink.
Probably the most important factor in a fluid-to-fluid heat exchanger is volume to surface area ratio. (not just frontal cross sectional surface area, but all surface area exposed to flow)
Because of its much greater structural strength compared to copper or brass, aluminum can be formed into tubes of smaller size and thinner section, arranged in greater density while still maintaining mechanical integrity. (Keep in mind these are pressurized systems. Surface area, which is good for cooling, is bad for strength.)
The practical result is that a <span style="font-style: italic">well designed</span> aluminum radiator can dissipate more heat in the same space.
Unfortunately, just because a radiator is made of aluminum doesn't mean it's designed or constructed well or even made of an appropriate alloy. And usable engineering specs are completely nonexistent for aftermarket radiators.
So buying one comes down to how much you trust your vendor.
pc.