The value in 5 speed conversion

[mightymidget]

We all know converting to a 5 speed is not for value conscious.

I see Bugeyes for sell and some mention that they are 5 speed cars, does this actually increase the value of car to cover cost of conversion. Does it just make the car a notch better than a standard Bugeye.

Appears to me the value is in the owners enjoyment only. Like most modifications this is to be expected.

Do you feel a 5 speed conversion adds value to a Bugeye and what amount. Seems the prices of Bugeyes are all over the place now, hard for me to tell.

 

[bugedd]

For me it does add value. Having the ability to drop into first gear while moving is huge, and is something that really bothered me about my previous car with the rib case. Also, 5th gear, which is overdrive, is great if you are doing some freeway miles and larger road trips. With the 3.9 ratio in the rear end and the 5 speed, I am spinning about 2600rpm at 65mph. I guess it really is all about you and your expectations from the car and the driving experience you are after.
Now as for how much value?? I'd say if you do the work yourself, it will cost around $2000 in parts to do the conversion, if you find the transmission for a reasonable price and it doesn't need a rebuild. Adding $2k to the price of a car for the conversion seems reasonable to me.

 

[nomad]

I have a 5 speed behind a 1275 in a midget and a 5 speed behind a A15 Datsun engine in a midget. Love them both but I like the BMC 4 speed enough that I'm just going to put a 3.7 diff in my bug eye.

Six of one...half dozen of another!:smile-new:

Kurt.

 

[59diamond]

I have had various combinations. 948 with a smooth case. 1275 with a rib case and now a 1275 with a Datsun 5 speed. The enjoyment I get with the 1275 and the 5 speed is without a doubt the most fun you can get out of a Bugeye. I also feel it is much safer when going up steep hills and when driving on the freeway. Syncro in first is really nice to have and 5th gear is beautiful. I could never go back to a 4 speed and 43 horsepower. Or even a 4 speed with say 70 horsepower. The combination of a 1275 and a 5 speed is unbeatable in my mind. I agree with everything Bugedd is saying except I am not sure about the value thing. Since I am hoping never to sell my Bugeye while I am alive I will let someone else worry about the value thing. The only thing is my Bugeye gives me extreme pleasure the way it is configured and that is all that matters to me.

 

[BillW103]

I put the 3.9 in the Bugey last year. With the hills and mountains in my area a 3.7 would be to high. I have a 5 speed and am saving for the install kit. If you were selling a Bugeye driver the 5 speed may make the sale. I hope my rib case holds out till I can put the 5 speed in.

 

[mightymidget]

So basically the value in a 5 speed conversion is in hi way driving and being able to downshift to 1st gear. I understand this.

If car is just going to be used for short trips around town the money spent would be not of a great value, also would not be returned when sold. eventually all cars are sold.

I just seeing the price of these cars appreciating and thinking it may be best to keep the original 4 speed. At my age I really don't see driving the car on long day trips

 

[nomad]

So basically the value in a 5 speed conversion is in hi way driving and being able to downshift to 1st gear. I understand this.

If car is just going to be used for short trips around town the money spent would be not of a great value, also would not be returned when sold. eventually all cars are sold.

I just seeing the price of these cars appreciating and thinking it may be best to keep the original 4 speed. At my age I really don't see driving the car on long day trips

The value of the 5 speed may be returned on sale of the car since its deemed highly desirable but it sound's like in your case personally you probably won't benefit.

Kurt/

 

[BillW103]

I have never driven another Sprite or Midget so I have nothing to compare to. The rib case I have is a 74 I think. Going up in the gears over 3k RPM I have to double clutch. All down shifting is double clutch. I don't know if this normal.
I had the 4.22 in at first and in town it was grate but I didn't like going on the freeway. The 3.9 is better on the freeway but doggie of the line. If you never leave town go with the 4.22 and 4 speed.

 

[nomad]

I have never driven another Sprite or Midget so I have nothing to compare to. The rib case I have is a 74 I think. Going up in the gears over 3k RPM I have to double clutch. All down shifting is double clutch. I don't know if this normal.
I had the 4.22 in at first and in town it was grate but I didn't like going on the freeway. The 3.9 is better on the freeway but doggie of the line. If you never leave town go with the 4.22 and 4 speed.

Bill, I'm afraid your trans is worn. The only place I double clutch is going from second to first.

Kurt.

 

[SD Bugeye]

I have a Rivergate kit I love driving and allowing others to drive my car.
this is easy it works has worked for 13-14 years now it's quite it shifts nice
it's full sync youngster don't struggle shifting they get to have a good experience without me cringing and gears griding
everyone has fun
and for me that's what it's all about so true it's not a purest car but this is fun to see friends enjoying it to.

 

[Boink]

The only place I double clutch is going from second to first.
Kurt.

Me too.

 

[mightymidget]

this is about the 10th MG/Sprite I have owned, so transmission 1st gear isn't that big a deal. I have driving commercial vehicles so transmission shifting is 2nd nature.

thanks for input

 

[BillW103]

I know my rib case is worn and I can drive it with no problem (I use to drive a truck with a 5&4) but I can't let any one ells drive it. I have a 5 speed that will go in eventually. There are times on hills I would like to get in first gear with out stopping.

 

[nomad]

First manual transmission vehicle I ever drove was a 52 Studebaker 2 ton truck with Studebaker's flat six. NO sycros in the transmission!! I got very good at double clutching! Had to shift constantly.

Kurt.

 

[mightymidget]

First manual transmission vehicle I ever drove was a 52 Studebaker 2 ton truck with Studebaker's flat six. NO sycros in the transmission!! I got very good at double clutching! Had to shift constantly.

Kurt.

don't forget the big steering wheel that kept your arm muscle toned

 

[Boink]

I figure with the graphite throw-out bearing, the less I shift the longer it will last.

 

[Gundy]

I have nothing to add to the Datsun thing, but....I LOVE the sc/cr box. Guess in many ways it is inferior to
the stock box. Loud, whiny, un synchro first that is tall. Heck I run a 4.2 just to save my clutch on the
start up the driveway. BUT....where I live/drive make a sc/cr box and a low rear gear a weapon.
I am sure it hurts the sales price too.
Fun/cool factor.

 

[mightymidget]

I live in the flat lands of coastal Carolina, tho mountain driving is so much more fun

 

[AN5Sprite]

I have never driven one with 5 speeds....

I have never been unhappy with only 4....

Maybe I'm easy to please....

I don't have any objections to 5, but I do think the conversion is probably too far from the spirit of what *I think of* as "British Motoring"...

No judgement, just my own feelings.