Well, I went out and made one. All I had was a half box of soda to play with.
Anyway, here is a before
And after
Like I said, I did not have much soda to work with, but the results are encouraging. Notice the oxidation is gone, it actually goes fast.
The setup leaves a lot to be desired. There is no control on the soda flow, so you get clumps (might be old soda) but when it comes out, wham, oxidation is gone.
It is also messy, I mean really messy, a cloud of soda wafted over the fence.
Given I am not looking for that polished look, just clean gray aluminum, this has been the least damaging and cheapest so far for me, and it gets into the crevices.
So I plan a trip to CostCo and get a couple of really big boxes of the stuff.
More pics after I move to the wood shed and blast some more.