[ QUOTE ]
I can find a fun car that will give me driving experience without the risk of being killed by anything more than a moped... speaking relatively, these cars have no where near the size, strength, or safety features necessary to save you from anything bigger than another Triumph. If you want to be jaded, go ahead, but I'd rather live when someone screws up or I screw up and hit something.
[/ QUOTE ]
It's your decision and sounds like you have pretty well made up your mind...
On the other hand, I'm not sure who's been talking to you, but it sounds like bull to me. I think you are underestimating the car, or overestimating modern safety devices, maybe both.
Yes, air bags are good, but those are probably the single "biggest" modern improvement that will really make a car safer and *can't* be fitted to a TR (AFAIK).
This is just my opinion, but it's based on personal experience.
Many years ago I was hit from behind by a drunk driver. I was in my TR4, stopped in a left turn lane, saw him coming but had nowhere to go, so I could only mash down hard on the brake pedal to keep from being pushed into oncoming traffic. I still got spun around pretty good.
That drunk was driving a full size 'Merican pickup truck, had 10 passengers in it with him and was estimated to be going more than 30 mph. He left no skid marks, so the cops guessed he never saw me and didn't even try to brake (improved rear lighting would be a good safety improvement on the older TRs).
The car and I were both damaged, but repairable. A shoulder belt and "street" roll bar probably helped prevent more injury, but the seat broke free (original lowback style) and I broke the steering wheel with my chest. The car's gas tank was punctured by the RH bracket, but fuel level was about half and none leaked out. I walked away with my worst injury being a cut on the back of my head, actually caused by the seat belt mounting bolt on the roll bar, of all things. (Note: I said I think the "street" roll bar helped, but in terms of adding some structural strength to the car. I have little confidence this type of bar would help much in an actual rollover, due to the fact that it's mounted on sheet metal rather than the frame and because it's somewhat narrow to allow the soft top to be raised and lowered. Thankfully, TRs are low-sitting and not inclined to roll over very easily.)
My point though, is that the car absorbed the impact pretty well and survived better than I'd have ever expected, protecting me in the process. In fact, many years later I was in a nearly identical accident in a VW Scirocco (modern safety features, unibody design with crumple zones, etc., but no air bags). This time I was hit from behind by a drunk in a full size van and pushed into the rear of another full size van that was fully stopped at a red light. The VW accordianed and was totalled, collapsing to the point that I had to crawl out a window.
Both the TR4 and the VW have great road holding characteristics and low center of gravity, are not inclined to roll over easily (something I've *seen* a modern SUV do all by itself on dry pavement at highway speeds, when a driver over-reacted). I think a sportscars' nimbleness might be helpful avoiding some accidents, too, although in my examples I had nowhere to go and just had to sit there and wait to be hit.
A good set of seat belts in a well-maintained TR, maybe also a roll bar, along with improved exterior lighting and quality seating, will go a long way toward protecting nearly as well as anything on the road today. During it's current restoration, my TR4 is getting at least a rally/autocross style roll cage, better high-back seats and 4- or 5-point harnesses. I will likely also go to brighter halogen bulbs in the tail lights and probably will add a high third brakelight, maybe on the rollbar. Because of the gas tank's location, I'm considering a fuel cell.
I'm a careful driver. Riding motorcycles all my life has taught me to watch out for the idiots. But things can and do happen anyway. The best we can do is prepare and be aware, no matter what we are driving.
I always wear a seatbelt, even though a college friend was killed *because* he was wearing one in what I consider a very unfortunate fluke accident (a low-speed roll over in a topless Jeep... his 3 passengers weren't wearing belts, were thrown clear, and walked away with minor scrapes and bruises). And, I don't drink and drive (although I might have done when I was young and very foolish!)
If a different car makes you feel safer, that's great. But, whatever you buy, preparedness and awareness will still be your most important "safety devices". I think a lot of drivers are lulled into a false sense of security because of all the fancy safety devices they have wrapped around them in their modern cars. Of course, I'm mostly on California freeways where drivers chat on a cell phone, sip their Starbucks, consult their Garmin and put on eye makeup, all at the same time while maintaining 75 mph and a single car length between their front bumper and the car ahead.
On a lighter note, a trunk rack might help with the luggage space concerns. I recall picking up a friend from the airport in college. She was returning from a two month holiday break and had her entire wardrobe with her... 5 large suitcases *will* fit in and on a TR, with the top down... in Colorado... in a January snow storm. It was only a 35 mile drive, thankfully! Thawing out was fun. /ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif
/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/cheers.gif