• Hey Guest!
    British Car Forum has been supporting enthusiasts for over 25 years by providing a great place to share our love for British cars. You can support our efforts by upgrading your membership for less than the dues of most car clubs. There are some perks with a member upgrade!
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Upgraded members don't see this banner, nor will you see the Google ads that appear on the site.)
Tips
Tips

TR4/4A Oh crud - coolant in the oil

Share this page

So the oil did not look like a milk shake after all? And there was no crud in the oil? I would take the thermostat out and see what happens and I would look for a plugged radiator. At 200 miles the oil should still be clean.
 
Good morning and thanks for the help.

sp53 said:
So the oil did not look like a milk shake after all?
Click to expand...

Turns out no milkshake. Oil was dirty looking but this was a fresh rebuild and not sure if that was just initial assembly lube.

sp53 said:
And there was no crud in the oil?
Click to expand...

no crud

sp53 said:
I would take the thermostat out and see what happens and I would look for a plugged radiator.
Click to expand...

Radiator was re-cored prior to being installed, but worth checking since maybe something came loose in the block water passages. There was some red-ish pebbly material on the radiator cap.
 
Any chance that some form of red sealing material was used for the head gasket, and some extra oozed out and into the cooling system? Just a WAG.

Dan
 
Aloha Dan. Might be, didn't seem metallic.

In doing some research it seems that antifreeze won't necessarily milkshake like water will. Is that accurate?
 
I've had it happen in 4.3 Blazer and yes it does look like a milkshake when mixed with oil. And hard to drain out as well. You are fortunate it did not get into the oil. How did the combustion gas test turn out. That test will confirm very quickly if the head gasket is leaking and over pressurizing the cooling system.

JVV
 
Hi guys - slow in providing an update on this but the news is not good.

I finally got around to pouring the oil I drained out of the 4a and after it had sat for last 45 days or so it clearly separated and there was crud in the bottom of the trays (I used several to drain the oil into) and there was a clear separation of the oil and coolant in the last one I poured into the larger tray.

Apparently the oil will not always froth, so be aware.

Sigh.
 
Maybe you caught it before the oil and coolant had a chance to mix and milkshake. That would be good news for your bearings, you never said how the combustion gas test turned out. That may be moot now that you found water in the oil. Pull the head and replace the head gasket.
 
JerryVV said:
Maybe you caught it before the oil and coolant had a chance to mix and milkshake. That would be good news for your bearings, you never said how the combustion gas test turned out. That may be moot now that you found water in the oil. Pull the head and replace the head gasket.
Click to expand...

Hi Jerry - thanks for the note back. Hoping I caught it in time, going to start tearing it down later today. Nothing to do but dive in I suppose.
 
BTW, the original aluminum plug in the top of the head, per Moss Tech Support, is 1 inch diameter and has 14 threads per inch SAE, and is 3/8 inch thick. It is not pipe thread.
Bob
 
Maybe not, but a 3/4" pipe plug will screw in and seal. The head on my previous TR3A was done that way before I got it, and never leaked again.
 
If the oil drained as just oil, why did you think you had coolant in the oil?
Just asking, as there is probably more to this story.
 
I hope it hasn't taken Tom 13 months to diagnose the problem...
 
Back
Top