• Hi Guest!
    You can help ensure that British Car Forum (BCF) continues to provide a great place to engage in the British car hobby! If you find BCF a beneficial community, please consider supporting our efforts with a subscription.
    There are some perks with a member upgrade!
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this gawd-aweful banner
Tips
Tips

TR2/3/3A Grinding noise when trying to start sometimes?

Share this page

M

Momikey

Senior Member
Offline
So sometimes Tr3a starts right up and then sometimes it try's and clicks. Today it made a grinding noise when trying to start. Is this a bad starter or what do you guys think?
 
Click can be several things...starter being one. Low battery. Bad or corroded cables. Bad or corroded solenoid contacts (it clicks, so start button and circuit is probably for this discussion okay).
Put a test light on the output lug of the solenoid and see what it does when you hit "start". Voltmeter would be better, but light will tell you.
Then do it on the starter cable lug.
Brushes bad will start usually with a balky start, get to the point you will need a hammer to get home the last time. That usually dances the brushes down that last little bit to get you home. BTDT.
Grinding can be several things...again, bad starter, low cranking voltage (depending on whether you have one of the new gear drive or original..and type of drive). Bendix units are "spun" out, needs a good kick, low voltage (cables, battery, solenoid) can sometimes give you a partial sling on the drive. Bad Bendix, bad ring gear...and don't keep doing that or it will be a bad ring gear.

Check battery voltage. Check voltage at solenoid and starter while someone holds the start button in. Any voltage drop is cables, connections or solenoid contacts.

That's a start.

May be a bad starter, but always a good idea to know the bits that feed the starter are up to snuff before you start changing parts out.
 
Also check to be sure that the starter mounting bolts are still secure.
 
TOC said:
Click can be several things...starter being one. Low battery. Bad or corroded cables. Bad or corroded solenoid contacts (it clicks, so start button and circuit is probably for this discussion okay).
Put a test light on the output lug of the solenoid and see what it does when you hit "start". Voltmeter would be better, but light will tell you.
Then do it on the starter cable lug.
Brushes bad will start usually with a balky start, get to the point you will need a hammer to get home the last time. That usually dances the brushes down that last little bit to get you home. BTDT.
Grinding can be several things...again, bad starter, low cranking voltage (depending on whether you have one of the new gear drive or original..and type of drive). Bendix units are "spun" out, needs a good kick, low voltage (cables, battery, solenoid) can sometimes give you a partial sling on the drive. Bad Bendix, bad ring gear...and don't keep doing that or it will be a bad ring gear.

Check battery voltage. Check voltage at solenoid and starter while someone holds the start button in. Any voltage drop is cables, connections or solenoid contacts.

That's a start.

May be a bad starter, but always a good idea to know the bits that feed the starter are up to snuff before you start changing parts out.
Click to expand...

What is a ring gear and where is it at?
 
And it may be fine now...but you keep grinding without finding the cause, won't take long and you will have a good blank spot where the full gear teeth used to be.
 
Ok I'm going to remove the starter and check it all out. Moss does not seam to have a rebuilt one for the early tr3a only the up graded hi torque starters which I guess would be better any way.
 
Well I put a new hi torque starter in today an I also hooked it up using the attached solenoid not only did the grinding noise go away but the car starts right up. I like it.
I plan on rebuilding the old starter if I can just to have the original parts saved.
 
There ya go! I can't recall off the top of me head the drive on a 2/3/3A, but I thought it was the old pull-in Bendix style.
Rust dirt and grease in the drive...or lots of old clutch facing dust...or remnants of throwout bearings...
Starter itself is probably just fine...check end float....but the drive can be the issue.

Tell me so I know...is the old unit pull-in drive (pulls the gear towards the starter and hits the rear part of the ring gear) and new one push out drive (hits front of ring gear)?
 
TOC said:
There ya go! I can't recall off the top of me head the drive on a 2/3/3A, but I thought it was the old pull-in Bendix style.
Rust dirt and grease in the drive...or lots of old clutch facing dust...or remnants of throwout bearings...
Starter itself is probably just fine...check end float....but the drive can be the issue.

Tell me so I know...is the old unit pull-in drive (pulls the gear towards the starter and hits the rear part of the ring gear) and new one push out drive (hits front of ring gear)?
Click to expand...
my old one looks like a bullet I think it pushed out but the teeth were a little chipped and it felt like it was wore out. The new one is a hi torque stater from British starters. It starts right away. Big difference.
 
Back
Top