• Hi Guest! Being a Paying Supporter is NOT a requirement to participate at BCF. However, subscribing will help ensure we can continue to serve the LBC community for years to come. If you enjoy BCF and find our forum a useful resource...Please consider supporting us by **Upgrading**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this banner)
Tips
Tips

TR4/4A Flat/dead spot on the starter?

tdskip

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
Hi guys - hope everyone's week is off to a good start.

Now the weather is (finally) cooling off a bit I am running around in the TR4a shaking her down for regular use. One recurring issue I am dealing with is that the starter has what appears to be a flat/dead spot. Here is what is going on:

1) Battery fully charged
2) Good grounds and solenoid connections
3) Used gear reduction starter
4) Sometimes she cranks to beat the band, starter easily cranks the engine over and she catches right away
5) Sometimes it will do a 1/2 crank and then bog to a point where the engine doesn't spin at all

#5 suggests to my eyes suggests I've got a bad starter and it needs to be pulled to be rebuilt.

What do you think? Yes/no/other ideas?
 

poolboy

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
When it bogs down, Tom, does the starter continue to spin, but the engine does not ?
 
OP
T

tdskip

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
Hi Ken - neither the starter nor the engine spins at that point.

it is a fresh engine rebuild and still a bit tight but since it spins over easily at some points it seems like starter.
 

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
Could well be the starter. On the gear drive now in my TR3, I found that the armature bearings had died and were letting the armature rub on the pole pieces.

Another possibility might be the centrifugal advance mechanism. If it is sticking in the advanced position sometimes, the engine may be trying to start backwards and fighting the starter.
 

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
I'd at least have it apart to see what the problem is. The bearings were easy to find at MMC, and the only special tool I used was a metric Allen wrench with a cheater bar. Fairly straightforward, but mark the relative position of the mounting flange before taking it loose. And don't lose the single bearing ball inside the output shaft. I just learned the other day that I apparently lost that ball, and that was why the starter wouldn't engage reliably.

Up to you on whether to rebuild or replace. Normally, I'd say a rebuild would be fine; but some years ago now I got 6 bad rebuilt alternators in a row! They all worked at first but failed within just a few weeks or months. Drove me crazy looking for what else was wrong, but I never did find anything and the last alternator lasted 3 or 4 years and was still working when my daughter traded the car in.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
71TR6 TR2/3/3A New engine mounts not sitting flat Triumph 41
B TR4/4A Head gasket won't lay flat Triumph 13
J TR2/3/3A Trunnions - Chamfered vs Flat Top Triumph 3
P TR2/3/3A TR3A Windshield Frame Curved or Flat? Triumph 7
T Modern Oils for Our Flat Tappet Engines Austin Healey 22
T Modern Oils for Our Flat Tappet Engines Spridgets 7
H Joan Baez flat floor '61 roadster, what did the Feds sell it for at auction? Jaguar 0
NutmegCT Flat head [L-head] engine question Other Cars 5
T TR2/3/3A Should I put flat washers on sump bolts? Triumph 3
H Joan Baex 1961 flat floor--silver exterior--anybody know what IRS sold it for? Jaguar 0
H Joan Baez flat floor series I e-type roadster: what did the authorities dump it for? Jaguar 0
R flat spot Spridgets 13
J Had a flat on the way to Mini Mania open house Austin Healey 4
drambuie Bonneville salt flat moment Austin Healey 15
M TR2/3/3A Repairing a flat tire on TR3 Triumph 15
glemon Series 1.5-2 E type, flat towed Spotted 0
J Oilcan spot on fender [IE: not flat, sticking out Triumph 2
Cottontop Flat towing a TR 4 Triumph 1
6TTR3A A FLAT TIRE ??? Triumph 13
J TR4/4A 67 TR4A IRS Hood Bumpers-Cones or Flat? Triumph 8
TR6oldtimer TR6 TR6 windscreen and rear flat black Triumph 4
Morris 9:1 flat top 1500 pistons Spridgets 0
Basil More Drool. A 3.8 Flat Floor EType! Jaguar 13
V flat towing? Triumph 10
T Curved vs flat glass - what is the scoop w/ that? Triumph 9
Stewart Flat spots at 4k and 5k MG 13
B Stupid Question..flat tire issue Spridgets 3
T Flat. Stopped. First or second gear? Austin Healey 4
Steve Morgan Flat Rad on eBay Other British Cars 6
MadMarx Tappet - flat or domed? that's the question Triumph 5
T Daddy, can we take the flat car? Triumph 14
Kirk_Fisher 1st flat tire Triumph 7
V TR6 TR6 Flat Tappet Triumph 12
SpannerMan Tire repair or fix-a-flat [wire wheels]. Triumph 11
J Flat tire/tube issues MG 8
F GT6 Domed or Flat pistons? GT6 MK3 Triumph 10
M Flat Spot on my Weber 32/36 DGV MG 3
MattP Just flat wrong Other Cars 14
B '61 flat floor roadster Jaguar 5
Mickey Richaud MGB MGB Flat Bar Luggage Rack MG 13
C HS2's...big ole' flat spot! Maybe I need to just pay someone. Triumph 27
A Flat spot, hesitiation, call it what you will... MG 17
W Flat spot? MG 8
S WANTED: Healey BN1 "Smiths" Fuel Gauge (Dead or Alive) Austin Healey Classifieds 3
R How old is "dead" FORUM Help 5
Busted knuckles TR2/3/3A Lead sled, spiral shank nails and dead battery box’s. Triumph 13
FlyingCat Spitfire Dead Starter? Triumph 18
Sopwith_Camel dead at the finish line Spridgets 10
6 Dead Circuit ARRGH! Spridgets 13
2billydavies TR2/3/3A dead battery, generator, belt Triumph 13

Similar threads

Top