The vac advance aids in better economy by advancing ignition under light throttle. Mechanical advance doesn't sense load like a Vac does. Vehicles with a vac advance tend to have a bit quiter exhaust at highway speeds too. You need/can use more advance when vacuum is high, ie, cruise speeds when A/F ratio is leaner. I converted my 1500 from vac retard to vac advance w/ the DGV and dual SU's. I liked it. Now that I have a DCOE, I wish I could still hook it up, but I like this carb better. For me, it's simpler and more responsive. Plus, I can get to my manifold nuts and dip stick easier. You may find a vac advance might make your DGV smoother.
I'm getting about the same milage with all three, sucky! (~21-22 mpg)