Just replaced the timing cover seal on my BJ8 which, of course, required removing the damper. I dropped the damper and knocked, yes, a quarter moon-shaped piece off the pulley (it surprised me that the pulley is cast iron). Since the damper has nearly 200K miles on it I decided to have it rebuilt; I've seen what happens when the rubber lets go and a damper comes apart on another car (it's not pretty). Damper Dudes brazed the chip back on, cleaned up some nicks on the damper and rebuilt the damper with new riubber 'buffer,' for about $160 inc. tax and shipping (one day turnaround). Note the new rubber will be recessed instead of 'proud,' which could be noted in concours:
https://www.damperdudes.net/
In order to get the damper off you have to raise the engine to clear the lower front cross-member, at least for a 6-cyl car but probably for a 4-cyl as well. This isn't too bad a job--worst part is getting the radiator out and back in--unbolt the engine from the motor mounts and detach the throttle linkage (I also undid the transmission tie rod, but that's probably not strictly necessary). I lifted the engine with a floor jack with a 2x4 on top--bad idea, the 2x4 left an impression in the pan (ended up using a larger flat piece of wood that contacted all 4 corners of the pan). The hard part will be getting the large nut off the end of the crank. I ended up buying a HF 3/4" impact wrench and (non-impact) socket. The wrench is too big to fit between the engine and front cross-bracing on my BJ8, so I had to go at the nut at an angle, which damaged the nut. Bought a new one--$45!--which is good quality EXCEPT it is threaded its whole length inside, which concerns me that the threads may have bottomed before the damper was fully seated (the original nut is beveled on the inside to prevent this). Note I have since seen a 'compact' 3/4" impact wrench from Klutch which might fit, and as the nut is 1 & 11/16" inch there are impact sockets for a Dodge hub nut that
should work.
While I was at it, I checked the water pump and as it had a slight bit of play and I'm going on a long road trip I replaced it with a rebuilt. You might as well pull the timing cover while you're at it, to inspect the chain, gears and chain damper, and replace the seal. I do think, but can't say for sure, that a ragged missing piece on the pulley could eventually tear up the belt.