I've got to admit that those screens on ebay were pretty homely...they must have been really rare but certainly not attractive. Something on the corners just didn't look right...
As far as the discussions on modified cars...Was a 30's Cadillac or Packard ruined when the original body, maybe a four door, replaced by a Dietrich or LeBaron cabriolet body? Certainly not original but generally accepted in the classic car world. There were dozens of big, luxury cars of that era that were re-bodied by other builders.
My brother is just finishing doing a six-figure restoration on a 1936 SS 100. He built a complete new body for it rather than hammer out the old, rough original aluminum tub. I doubt if any Jaguar affecionado would dare to call that car "modified".
I wonder if the preservasionists who restore old houses insist on knob and tube wiring, coal furnaces, wood kitchen stoves and gas lights to keep their projects "original".
I haven't seen many people tear out their bathrooms only to build a privey in the backyard.
There's plenty of room in this hobby for vehicles of all classes. Many an old car was resurrected from junkyards to be reborn as a young man's hot rod or race car. Many cars that I have personal knowledge of were constructed from parts that were considered too rough for the restorers.
Sure, once in awhile some "big spender" comes along and deflowers some virgin tin and rebuilds it to his liking. But that only increases the value of the remaining stockers...not a bad thing that supply and demand deal.
Now those of you who have seen my long-winded ramblings here know that my present TR2 project is going to be as bone-stock and original as I can make it. I just spent over $200.00 to secure two original tail lights and bezels from Europe...that's a big commitment for me. I could have kept the TR3 lights that were on it but I want this car original.
But 15 feet away from it in the next stall in my shop is a 500HP Ford pick-up that's been whacked 6 inches here and 14 inches there, has had a major heart transplant and has been injected (actually carbureted) with more steroids than Barry Bonds and Mark McGuire combined.
But I like 'em both...call me crazy but they are both fun and that's why I love this disease we call the car hobby...
End of Rant...we will now return you to our regularly scheduled programing...