• Hey Guest!
    British Car Forum has been supporting enthusiasts for over 25 years by providing a great place to share our love for British cars. You can support our efforts by upgrading your membership for less than the dues of most car clubs. There are some perks with a member upgrade!

    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Upgraded members don't see this banner, nor will you see the Google ads that appear on the site.)

General Tech Water Pump and Pulley Replacement

KVH

Obi Wan
Silver
Offline
It can’t be more than 3 years old, and it’s leaking. I’d like to remove it without removing the radiator this time. Question: Assuming I get the pump off and back on without any major issue, what about getting that pulley back on? There’s no room to swing a rubber hammer or otherwise “tap” the pulley back over the woodruff key. Unless really light tapping is all it takes. Should I just resign to remove the radiator or does any of you have experience on making this little task easy?

I once had a pulley go on really easy, only binding slightly on the key, but I understand it’s supposed to be snug.

I’m also wondering the best way to hold the pulley still while I retighten the locknut on the shaft. My air drill won’t fit, but I could try just binding it with the fan belt. Would a strap wrench do much good?

Any thoughts appreciated.
 
It can’t be more than 3 years old, and it’s leaking. I’d like to remove it without removing the radiator this time. Question: Assuming I get the pump off and back on without any major issue, what about getting that pulley back on? There’s no room to swing a rubber hammer or otherwise “tap” the pulley back over the woodruff key. Unless really light tapping is all it takes. Should I just resign to remove the radiator or does any of you have experience on making this little task easy?

I once had a pulley go on really easy, only binding slightly on the key, but I understand it’s supposed to be snug.

I’m also wondering the best way to hold the pulley still while I retighten the locknut on the shaft. My air drill won’t fit, but I could try just binding it with the fan belt. Would a strap wrench do much good?

Any thoughts appreciated.
The pump and pulley come off together. You then can separate the pulley from the old pump. Put it on the new pump ( hopefully it fits appropriately) and then install them as a unit.
Charley
 
Sure makes sense, and memory can fail, but wasn’t there some issue of clearance on both the fastening nuts/studs and the long bolt shown in the shop manual, if you didn’t remove the pulley first, and maybe same issue on reinstall where the pulley should go on last? Lack of clearance to manipulate and tighten the nuts?

BTW, my setup has three studs and nuts, and the long bolt shown in the manual, referring to “two” such bolts, does not exist on my TR4A. Maybe a change after the TR4.

(I’m going to order a new water pump. I’m not comfortable I could rebuild successfully)
 
The replacement of the long bolt with a stud is an intelligent former owner handywork.
Charley
 
FYI, I’ve removed the fastening nuts for the water pump, but the gasket sealer is holding like a weld. So far, putty knives and light chisels have done nothing. I’m sure I’ll get the pump off, but it’s going to be a process. Next time I’ll be sure to use Permatex High Tack or something like that.
 
Make sure that the key slots in the shaft and the pulley are the same width. OE was 1/8 inch and my last replacement pump had a 3mm slot in the shaft.
Bob
 
Remember if the pump is trash, you can be more aggressive with what you use as long as you are hitting the pump itself.
Charley
 
I have replaced the smaller pump part and left the housing in place and purchased a new pump and pulley, so I knew they would match up.
 
I would avoid trying to wedge something like a chisel between the pump and housing, you’ll just screw up the mating surface. Try hitting the pump with a plastic faced dead blow hammer.
 
Be aware that if you replace the original 4 vane pump with one of the "improved" 5 vane pumps from Moss that you may find the exterior machining on the new pump interferes against the interior of the original pulley requiring the purchase of a new pulley as well. My two bits is these newer pumps actually may not perform any better(and possibly worse) than the original 4 vane pumps due to their much lower tolerance between the impeller and the pump housing.
 

Attachments

  • 2026-10-07 23.41.55.jpg
    2026-10-07 23.41.55.jpg
    920.5 KB · Views: 47
  • 2026-10-07 23.42.26.jpg
    2026-10-07 23.42.26.jpg
    649.2 KB · Views: 48
Some years ago I bought the classic gold uprated 5 vane pump for a spare and sent it right back after measuring the shaft .001 under size.
Tom
 
I was being too gentle. I whacked it with a regular hammer, but carefully in the groove with a chisel. Got it off. All sealed up, but tightening that nut for the pulley was an experience. I went to O’Reilly’s and bought a good strap wrench. It’s hard to find anything that’s this much fun.

I must say, though, that removing and replacing the fan belt by first raising the engine’s crank pulley extension above the steering cross-bar, and then completely removing the alternator/generator to fit the fan belt “first” since it simply will not fit if the alternator/generator is first put in place, is quite a sight for an onlooker to see. My friend who was watching me said he’d help if he had any idea what the heck I was trying to do.
 
Last edited:
I was being too gentle. I whacked it with a regular hammer, but carefully in the groove with a chisel. Got it off. All sealed up, but tightening that nut for the pulley was an experience. I went to O’Reilly’s and bought a good strap wrench. It’s hard to find anything that’s this much fun.

I must say, though, that removing and replacing the fan belt by first raising the engine’s crank pulley extension above the steering cross-bar, and then completely removing the alternator/generator to fit the fan belt “first” since it simply will not fit if the alternator/generator is first put in place, is quite a sight for an onlooker to see. My friend who was watching me said he’d help if he had any idea what the heck I was trying to do.
It sounds to me that your belt may be a bit short. When I put a alternator on I got a longer belt. I just changed my water pump yesterday and hadnone of your problems.
Also to tighten the nut holding the pulley I use a woodworking vice to clamp down the impeller and tighten the nut.
Charley
 
I have replaced a fan belt by turning the steering wheel side to side to let the belt slip through steering leankage.
 
It sounds to me that your belt may be a bit short. When I put a alternator on I got a longer belt. I just changed my water pump yesterday and hadnone of your problems.
Also to tighten the nut holding the pulley I use a woodworking vice to clamp down the impeller and tighten the nut.
Charley
Yes I think when I order a new belt there’s one out there about .5 inches longer. I had several places on the phone and was surprised by the limited options once you’ve decided to keep the wide belt.
 
Yes I think when I order a new belt there’s one out there about .5 inches longer. I had several places on the phone and was surprised by the limited options once you’ve decided to keep the wide belt.
Here is a pic of the belt I am using. I do have a smaller pulley on the alternator.
That is a NAPA belt. 25-28400.
Charley
 

Attachments

  • 20230719_210458.jpg
    20230719_210458.jpg
    1 MB · Views: 17
Back
Top