• Hey there Guest!
    If you enjoy BCF and find our forum a useful resource, if you appreciate not having ads pop up all over the place and you want to ensure we can stay online - Please consider supporting with an "optional" low-cost annual subscription.
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this UGLY banner)
Tips
Tips

"Black Box" inspection

aeronca65t

Great Pumpkin
Offline
"Black Box" inspection

Last week I took the Miata for New Jersey state vehicle inspection (similar to MoT in the UK)....and I was sort of surprised.

In the past, New Jersey tested tailpipe emissions while the car idled in neutral.
A few years ago, our state Governor (Christie Whitman) embarked on a plan to privatize state inspection and test every car using a wheel driven dynamometer (sometimes called a "rolling road"). Emissions were tested at idle and about 35 MPH in high gear.
I think it's safe to say that this emissions-test system brought together Republicans and Democrats: we *all* thought this scheme was a disaster. It also cost NJ tapayers a fortune.
Two of my other cars were tested using this method recently, and both eventually passed after several annoying return visits.

When I took the Miata in, I figured it would get the "dyno-test" also. Instead, the inspection guy raised the hood ("bonnet" to you Brits) on the car and plugged a cable into the ALDL port (the diagnostic connector). After a few moments, the unit recorded a "PASS" and I was good-to-go (after they checked lights, brakes, front-end and a few other items). Evidently, the internal computer records emissions problems well enough to satisfy our state inspection. All NJ vehicles starting with 2000 model year will get this form of emissions test.
Eventually, as pre-2000 cars become rarer, those expensive dynos will be phased out, replaced by querying the "Black Box".

Personally, I have no problem with a formal state inspection (our's is every two years). If it keeps the death-traps and gross polluters off the road, I'm all for it.
But the use of the Black Box surprised me. I wonder what they'll do to test the Miata in 25 years?

Interestingly, these "Black Boxes" can have other implications. Congressman Bill Janklow was recently charged with blowing through a Stop sign and running over a motorcyclist with his Cadillac (the biker died). The car's Black Box was used as evidence against Janklow (it recorded his speed at the time of the accident....over 70 MPH).


Note: New Jersey continues to have two types of "Historic License plates", for car owners wishing to avoid emissions testing (and willing to limit yearly driving mileage). Cars must be at least 25 years old. My Sprite is registered this way.

[ 09-22-2003: Message edited by: aeronca65t ]</p>
 

waltesefalcon

Yoda
Silver
Country flag
Offline
Re: "Black Box" inspection

Nial,

Don't you mean historic plates are for those willing to unhook their speedo cables most of the year rather then limit thier driving?

Cheers,
thirsty.gif
driving.gif

Walter
 

tony barnhill

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
Re: "Black Box" inspection

iagree.gif
&, not sure I'm 100% behind vehicle inspections...seems they only put $$$'s in the states' coffers...we don't have them in Alabama but in states where I've lived, they were a joke...I remember my Renault Fuego Turbo that was one of the cars used for magazine testing; Renault had made some serious mods to the car to ensure praise from the test drivers - however, it wouldn't pass emissions controls so the dealer always 'detuned' it enough for me to pass & then 'retuned' it immediately afterwards!
 
OP
aeronca65t

aeronca65t

Great Pumpkin
Offline
Re: "Black Box" inspection

Shhhh! Guys, lets not let out our dirty little secrets about post-emission test "re-tuning" and "acidentally" disconnected speedo-cables!

Actually, Connecticut has unlimited mileage for Historic plates, but most insurance companies set a limit of 2500 miles per year anyway.

I agree that state inspection can be a joke (I'd bet that most of us at BCF take reasonable care of our cars and probably don't need it). But in the rural area I live in, I've seen some real "bombs".....doors closed with a rope, bumpers dragging, windshield smashed beyond belief, etc.. A lot of these bombs get overlooked if they're driven locally (because the driver's are often "locals", and they know the local police), but eventually, state inspection gets them off the road (and into the demoliton derby, where they belong!)
 

DougR

Jedi Trainee
Country flag
Offline
Re: "Black Box" inspection

I wouldn't mind having a vehicle safety inspection here in Calif. We have to smog test to get registration, but even if your tires will only temporarily hold air, "Happy motoring!"

(could at least have the Boy Scouts inspect the knots in the bumper "brackets")
iagree.gif
 
OP
aeronca65t

aeronca65t

Great Pumpkin
Offline
Re: "Black Box" inspection

This was in today's NY Times....it kind of relates to the "big-brother" aspect of these black-boxes that I've been wondering about (Sorry...it's fairly long):

WASHINGTON, Sept. 22 — California today adopted the nation's first law meant to protect the privacy of drivers whose cars are equipped with "black boxes," or data recorders that can be used to gather vital information on how a vehicle is being driven in the last seconds before a crash.

Gov. Gray Davis signed the law, which takes effect on July 1, requiring carmakers to disclose the existence of such devices and forbidding access to the data without either a court order or the owner's permission, unless it is for a safety study in which the information cannot be traced back to the car.

More than 25 million cars and trucks have the boxes that measure speed, air-bag deployment and the use of brakes, seat belts and turn signals. But California's privacy law is the first of its kind, says Thomas M. Kowalick, co-chairman of a committee convened by the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers to set standards for the boxes. Most of the recorders are on General Motors vehicles, but Ford and others have deployed some. Other manufacturers have plans to do the same.

The police in South Dakota sought information from such a recorder to determine whether Bill Janklow, a member of the House of Representatives and a former governor of the state, had run a stop sign and was speeding on Aug. 16 when he hit and killed a motorcycle rider near Flandreau. But Maj. James Carpenter of the South Dakota Highway Patrol said that because the car was not a recent model — it was a 1995 Cadillac — it had limited information.

The California bill was introduced by Tim Leslie, a Republican assemblyman, who contended that the devices were installed without the owner's knowledge or consent and that the information they gathered should be subject to the same legal protections as provided by the Fourth Amendment for other kinds of private information. He compared it to the process for getting permission to tap a telephone.

Mr. Leslie's legislative director, Kevin O'Neill, said in a telephone interview that in the case of a crash that resulted in civil litigation or criminal prosecution, the data would be obtainable by court order. But the information should be protected by a process, Mr. O'Neill said.
 
Offline
Re: "Black Box" inspection

Just one more reason to rebuild what ya got

Mark
 

spritenut

Luke Skywalker
Offline
Re: "Black Box" inspection

My 01 Ford went on the dyno at NJ inspection this year. Maybe not ALL 2000s and up have these black boxes.
As for NJ inspections, I have 3 LBCs registered historic and one PIECES, my RH drive Sprite is registered normally and has to get inspected every 2 years. Last time they failed me because my left side mirror was missing. I told him the car is RIGHT hand drive, he quoted NJ law requiring 1 outside mirror on the LEFT side of the car. I had one on the right side, the drivers side!
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
G Black Box Spridgets 4
M TR2/3/3A Two black wires on control box E where do they g0 after alternator conversion? Triumph 9
T MGC MGC air intake box supposed to be gloss black? MG 12
71TR6 TR2/3/3A Aftermarket brake and clutch master cylinders - black extension? Triumph 6
angelfj1 TR5/TR250 TR250 Need Help identifying wires (2 - black) feeding starting solenoid Triumph 6
T For Sale MGB Black Label Overdrive For Sale Or Trade For New RB Parts MG Classifieds 2
tr6nitjulius General TR Sir John Black Drive Your TRIUMPH Day 2/10/22 Triumph 0
G TR6 Engine Cutout, Black Smoke, Large Backfire Triumph 7
KiwiStagguy For Sale Stag Black Mohair New top Cheap Triumph Classifieds 0
somewhatspritely The black paint on replacement panels. Restoration & Tools 7
J For Sale Triumph TR2 TR3 TR3A New Moss Motors Black Karvel Style Carpet Kit Triumph Classifieds 0
Leatherman Wanted Red and black TR2 / 3 front emblem Triumph Classifieds 6
L For Sale 1964 Austin FX4 Black Cab Other British Classifieds 0
B For Sale Brand New Black Tonneau Cover for BN4 and BT7 - for Right Hand Drive Car Austin Healey Classifieds 0
HealeyRick Just in Time for Black Friday Austin Healey 0
Jim_Stevens TR2/3/3A Rear fender stays: black or body color? Triumph 8
steveg Conclave Deadwood 2019 - Black Hills Maps Austin Healey 2
D TR6 1976 TR6 Black Painted Parts Triumph 2
M TR2/3/3A For those with blue/white/black TR3 badges Triumph 7
C I'm looking at a 1974 MG Midget [chrome bumpers with black sabrinas] Spridgets 9
JPSmit DeWalt or Black and Decker or DeWalt or ???? Restoration & Tools 4
mrv8q TR2/3/3A Califiornia Black Plate Syncronicity Triumph 1
Rhodyspit75 TR2/3/3A Speed is the new black. TR3 Triumph 5
AngliaGT Black Lightning Motorcycle Cafe British Motorbikes 2
C For Sale 1965 TR4 Red - Black Interior Triumph Classifieds 4
AH67 General TR Touch up Paint 11/PAA Black Triumph 2
Zitch For Sale FS- Brand new Black TR4 Deluxe Carpet Kit Triumph Classifieds 2
Jim_Gruber New Tiew Rod Ends. Paint Black Y/N Spridgets 5
Jim_Gruber Paint Color - Black Satin or Black Glossy for Suspension components Spridgets 9
Csarneson BP Northwest Black Friday Sale Austin Healey 0
Jim_Gruber BE Gauges and Speedhut - Is it a 3 3/8" Gauge???? now 20% off Black Friday Sale Spridgets 10
K TR4/4A Black marks on a TR4A/TR6 vinyl top boot cover? Triumph 4
Chancevought953 Black welt piping on aluminum surrounds Austin Healey 1
S TR2/3/3A black epoxy primer Triumph 1
Sopwith_Camel the black wire or the black wire or the black wire or the black wire Jaguar 3
M TR4/4A Carpet....Black or Charcoal Grey? Triumph 9
paul9999 London Black Cab Other British Cars 18
Martinld123 Small Puff of Black Smoke When I Blip Throttle Austin Healey 6
T TR6 Black sooty plugs continue - What now? Triumph 29
tahoe healey tire black Austin Healey 13
B Replacement of Small Black Wire inside Distributor Austin Healey 15
R TR4/4A What color black paint in hte interior Triumph 1
Got_All_4 TR2/3/3A Gloss black or satin black paint Triumph 17
R BN6 Brake Drums, Black or Aluminum/Silver? Austin Healey 3
60TR3A Should My '63 BJ7's Carburetors Have Brass Caps or Black Plastic? Austin Healey 3
AH100M Why weren't sill and wing flanges painted black on BN1s and BN2s? Austin Healey 12
jollyroger Black seat kits for 62 sprite/midget Spridgets 6
R removing black seam sealing Austin Healey 3
DerekJ Primrose Yellow / Black with yellow upholstery Austin Healey 18
T black snaps for convertible top Triumph 11

Similar threads

Top