I've now run a second set of items through the rock tumbler. Where the first group was mostly gunked up with grease and paint, and could probably have come out of the tumbler in less than 12 hours, the second set was covered with rust and was a tougher cleaning job. For example, I included the four thumb screw that hold on my side curtains. I put them in before dinner last night and pulled them out today around lunchtime, so they had about 18 hours in the tub. They are as sparkly and clean as though they were brand new. The thumb screws could use a little hand brushing in the screw slot, but the knurling is pristine.
The wire brush wheel method works if you are in a hurry and don't mind a little marring of the finish. I am also concerned about ruining the threads on some of the screws and bolts. I used the wire wheel on some of the larger pieces that would never fit into the rock tumbler. As I mentioned in one of my posts under "Painting the Master Cylinder," the wire wheel also poses the risk of propelling small bits out into the great beyond. Or injecting them into your abdomen. Or your eye. Or your dog.
The rock tumbler is also an exercise in forced patience for me. I am, by nature, an impatient person. My little car does not work on this theory. Having to wait 12-18 hours to get clean nuts, bolts, screws and washers means I have the time to do a slow and methodical job on everything else.
For my next round of tumbling, I am planning on using some different grit material. I have used up the little bag that came with the tumbler.