I have been supplying the rubber O-rings for Smith and Jaeger gauges for decades. The inner rings are now made in sponge to give a better fit. Try www.britcot.com
IMPORTANT: Please be aware that there are a lot of scammers on forums like this, so please exercise due diligence as we can't be responsible for transactions between members. See this thread for at least one type of scam to be aware of:
Private Message Scam (there may be others)
If you are suspect of a member being a scammer, please send me a PM with details.