I've heard the PT-22 glides like a stone. Apparently he tried to return to the runway.
So this may have been the best possible result of a bad situation (and yeah....best to land in a place where there are probably lots of doctors standing around). I've heard the live ATC radio of his distress call that day...he sounded very calm and in control.
Many of us have heard the old idea that it's best not to do a U-turn at low AGL but I think
"It depends".
One time during climb-out around 300' AGL my motor went "soft" due to carb clog (kept running but slowly). I did a U-turn and brought it back in with no issues (trying to land straight ahead in that situation would have been a massive problem).
My flight instructor had a crankshaft fail in a Super Cub at about 250' AGL. He also did a U-turn and was able to (barely) make it back, although it was a pretty hard landing with some damage. But again, probably a better outcome than going forward at our particular airport.
By the way, I had my A&P clean out the carb on my plane and a few days later the engine went "soft" again. Luckily at about 1500' AGL. I couldn't make it back to my airport, but the engine kept running at low speed (approx. 1400 RPM) so I was able to glide to a local "farmer grass strip". My A&P had to come over to fix it (plus give me a ride home). I wasn't exactly thrilled but this stuff happens in old planes so you can't get too excited about it.
Once, we had a glider from another airport get lost and land at our place. Our runway is too short for towing out so it had to have the wings pulled and it went out on a trailer.
Anyone who flies usually ends up with some stories they may
not want to share. I'll just leave it at that......
