The electric tach from 65-67 are the correct size.
And if you stay + grd, it's just a bit of wireing.
The scale on the electric tach does not match the face plate of the bugeye tach.
You can also use the guts from a smallet later 68-79 Spridget.
I use them on - grd cars but stick the guts in the older, larger housings so they fit the dash.
Now, people say they want the "correct" speedo and tach, the silver faced ones, for their Bugeyes but the smaller gauges have black faces. So if you stick a 65-67 speedo and tach in the Bugeye, all the gauges match. My personal opinion and it's what I do.