hondo402000 said:
I believe the only reason your amp needle will move is if the generator is trying to charge the battery, if you turn on the lights with out the engine runing you should show a move toward discharge, if the battery is low and you run the car the generator will put out to charge the battery up and the needle should move to the plus side, once the battery is charged up the generator would put out enough charge to run the electrics in the car and not off the battery and your needle should stay close to 0
That is correct; but starting the engine will always drain enough from the battery that the generator should try to charge it as soon as the rpm comes up high enough for the generator to work. With the generator putting out it's maximum of 21 amps (19 for earlier TRs), it takes many minutes of high speed driving to recharge the battery from even an easy start; it won't happen just revving the engine in the driveway.
Most mornings, my TR3 starts on the second turn. If the battery was fully charged when I parked the day before (meaning I didn't drive home with the headlights on), the battery will be recharged and the ammeter drop to near 0 within 5-10 minutes of freeway driving. But the first time I pull up to a red light, the battery discharges while the engine is idling, and then recharges again as soon as I take off. It's a constant cycle, when driving in city traffic.
With headlights on, the cycle is much more pronounced. Takes about 10 amps to run all the lights, so the battery runs down quicker with the engine idling (at 800 engine rpm, the generator is doing basically nothing, you may even see the red light glowing to indicate that the cutout opened). And the original generator doesn't have much capacity left over for charging the battery after it powers the lights and ignition. That means it takes much longer to put back the charge.
Which, in a largish nutshell, is why many people opt to upgrade to an alternator. Even a "mini" alternator will generally have twice the capacity of the stock generator, plus they will usually put out a fair amount of current even at idle. I had a 60 amp alternator in the (now wrecked) 3A; and while the ammeter would still kick up after every start, it would drop back down within a minute or two.