• Hey there Guest!
    If you enjoy BCF and find our forum a useful resource, if you appreciate not having ads pop up all over the place and you want to ensure we can stay online - Please consider supporting with an "optional" low-cost annual subscription.
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this UGLY banner)
Tips
Tips

Another senior moment

Share this page

C

CaptRandy

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
If there is a draw on battery with engine off, lights off, etc, will I only see an arc and spark when I disconnect + cable or will it also happen with the - cable? Negative ground car.
 
Keoke

Keoke

Great Pumpkin
Country flag
Offline
The answer to your question is YES If there is a draw on battery with engine off and all accessories.

A modern type Radio with a memory might be the exception here.
 
Lotuswins

Lotuswins

Jedi Trainee
Country flag
Offline
You will get an arc/spark from which ever pole you disconnect first, and as Keoke points out, only if you have a load on the system. You will also get an arc when reconnecting, even if no load, as the battery charges the capacitance of the wiring/system of the car. It won't spark again if you disconnect/reconnect though since you've already charged the system, unless there is a load on the system like the newer radios which syphon a little off the battery to keep the memory/etc. energized.

hope this helps, having problems??
 
OP
C

CaptRandy

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
No, just when pulling off negative cable today experienced no arc/spark and wondered. I do know for some reason in the past it was always advisable to pull neg first but can't remember why. When I say in the past I am thinking 50+ years ago when I first learned that.
 
healeyblue

healeyblue

Jedi Warrior
Gold
Country flag
Offline
The school of thought is to pull the "ground" cable first to prevent arcing. The arcing in this case is if your wrench were to slip and hit a metal portion of the car while still connected to the battery terminal. It would not spark at all if you did this on the ground cable. "Ground" could be positive or negative depending on how our cars are set up, so don't get into the thinking that just the negative cable is the safest to disconnect.
 
Keoke

Keoke

Great Pumpkin
Country flag
Offline
healeyblue said:
The school of thought is to pull the "ground" cable first to prevent arcing. The arcing in this case is if your wrench were to slip and hit a metal portion of the car while still connected to the battery terminal. It would not spark at all if you did this on the ground cable. "Ground" could be positive or negative depending on how our cars are set up, so don't get into the thinking that just the negative cable is the safest to disconnect.
Click to expand...

:iagree:--------Spot on !!
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
M Dang Another Senior Moment Triumph 3
Y MGB Time for another puzzle piece.... MG 5
P Another beautiful Sunday Spotted 0
L T-Series Another brake prob. ? MG 12
T I added another TVR to the fleet. TVR 10
AngliaGT ANOTHER TR6,& an MGB Spotted 0
Rut MGB Another sad day! MG 10
T General TR Another trans popping out of 2nd Triumph 14
K TR2/3/3A Another electrical problem: Park light & 5ignal light on Drivers side are brighter than....... Triumph 3
JPSmit you won't likely see another Spridgets 4
D TR2/3/3A Another mystery part(s) Triumph 2
Hamish Racing Another 3 sisters spring with commentary Racing 0
K TR2/3/3A Another brake bleed question....... Triumph 17
Sarastro Another SoCal TR3 Spotted 1
7 Wedge Got another one! Triumph 3
Sarastro TR4/4A Another 50K TR4A Triumph 5
D TR2/3/3A Another mystery part Triumph 8
HealeyRick GT6 Another Satisfied Customer Triumph 3
nichola TR6 Another TR6 back on the road Triumph 1
Sherlock Another cruise night, more interesting British iron Spotted 2
D TR2/3/3A Another Carb question. Triumph 22
Healey Nut Another Use for J-B Weld Austin Healey 5
D TR2/3/3A Have exchanged one leak for another. Triumph 10
dbenichou289 TR2/3/3A Another exhausting thread Triumph 10
D TR2/3/3A Another mystery part..or two Triumph 14
John Turney Another Article to Criticize Austin Healey 5
tr6nitjulius TR6 TR6 made another list! Triumph 5
Lin Another Trafficator/Control Head Question Austin Healey 10
Rob Glasgow Can I find Another one as Good? Austin Healey 4
V LED light bulbs : One thing leads to another Spridgets 7
V LED light bulbs : One thing leads to another Austin Healey 2
Editor_Reid Bought Another One Austin Healey 14
tr6nitjulius General TR Triumphest 2019 another one bites the dust! Triumph 2
pkmh Yet Another Oil Question! Austin Healey 8
P TR2/3/3A Another Differential Question Triumph 22
Bob Claffie Spotted another AH Spotted 0
SherpaPilot TR6 Just Another TR6 Column Question Triumph 4
TomMull Post-War Other HERALD Simple Task turns into another project. Triumph 11
jackq Another building full of cars available. Other Cars 0
M TR2/3/3A Another TR3 Piston Ring Gap Question Triumph 1
Lin Another trafficator issue Austin Healey 8
B Another OD question Austin Healey 32
Elva164 Finally did another onboard video! Racing 4
Sarastro TR4/4A Another milestone: first engine start Triumph 8
RAC68 Another Discussion of Trans/OD Fluid Austin Healey 14
Y MGB Another question - this time on seatbelts.... MG 2
PC another one bites the dust... Restoration & Tools 0
AngliaGT Another MGB Spotted 0
J Another Healey back on the road....for now. Austin Healey 8
D TR6 Another Newb Question Triumph 10

Similar threads

Top