• Hey there Guest!
    If you enjoy BCF and find our forum a useful resource, if you appreciate not having ads pop up all over the place and you want to ensure we can stay online - Please consider supporting with an "optional" low-cost annual subscription.
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this UGLY banner)
Tips
Tips

TR4/4A Answer to my post "help with tr4 transmission disassembly".

John_Progess

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
Well I finally got the cluster gear out. It looks like some PO did not install the rear cluster gear shaft bearing deep enough in the shaft. The rear most needle retaining ring with the lip to hold the needles was completely gone and what appears to be the outside cage of the bearing was left proud of the cluster gear by about 1/64" and this caught the inside of the thrust bearing and would not let it slide out. I had to pound down the proud lip and the thrust bearing finally slid out and the gear came right out. There still appears to be the outside of the needle bearing cage along with the forward needle retaining ring attached to it still inside the shaft. I will have to dig this out for the new bearing to fit. With the rear bearing retaining ring left proud of the shaft I don't see how the PO got this thing together! The thrust bearing was gouged out where the proud part of he bearing rubbed against it. Have a good day!

John
 
OP
J

John_Progess

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
Bob,
I will try to get some close up pictures today before I proceed. If you will send me a PM with your email I will send them to you. Have a good day!

John
 
OP
J

John_Progess

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
Here are some pictures of the cluster gear end, thrust washer, and needle bearing shell after I removed it from inside the shaft. IMG_2193.jpgIMG_2194.jpgIMG_2195.jpgIMG_2189.jpgIMG_2200.jpg
 

titanic

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
John-I would think that the bearing "walked" out after installation. Red loctite might be good insurance to prevent it from happening again. Is the bearing a tight fit in the cluster gear bore?
Berry
 

CJD

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
With the rear bearing retaining ring left proud of the shaft I don't see how the PO got this thing together! The thrust bearing was gouged out where the proud part of he bearing rubbed against it. Have a good day!

John

Never underestimate what a shade tree mechanic with a hammer can make fit!
 
OP
J

John_Progess

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
I had to drive out the bearing shell with a tool I made. It was tight! Is it normal to have to use lock tight when installing these bearings? Obviously I did something wrong when I inserted the images. Thanks for your response!

John
 

CJD

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
No need for locktite. There is no side force on the needles, so the cage will stay where you put it. The PM just did not "put it" right.
 

titanic

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
Normally, the shell bearing should be a press fit. The only scenario I can imagine that would require loctite, is if a cluster gear from a TR6 with a worn bore was fitted in a previous rebuild. Tr6s were fitted with open cage bearings, in which the bore of the cluster gear acts as the outer race. If the race becomes worn, it is common practice to fit the shell type bearing to salvage it. In which case, the fit could be loose and loctite might be used as a last resort.
Also, according to the shop manual, retaining rings&circlips were not used with the press fit shell bearings.
Sorry if I muddied the waters. I can't understand why the PO would fit the bearing proud of the gear.
Berry
 

TuffTR250

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
John, thanks for posting the pictures! Gives us good insight on what to avoid when rebuilding a transmission.
Regards, Bob
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Y MGB Answer to a question creates more new questions.... MG 12
S TR4/4A Any 4A owner can answer this question Triumph 6
B TR2/3/3A I need a definitive answer about 57 seats vs 59 seats Triumph 3
jlaird I use to know the answer but forgot. Spridgets 1
jlaird Spritenuts answer to electrics Spridgets 11
D How do you answer this? Triumph 49
jlaird Answer Spridgets 2
L Head stud question. Need answer urgently! Spridgets 4
Rob Glasgow High Beam Indicator Color - At last the answer Austin Healey 3
T Now What.....the answer Triumph 2
Brosky TR6 Answer to TR6 Rotor problems...and they're RED!! Triumph 18
Brosky TR6 For those looking for a restored TR6, your answer Triumph 21
Brosky TR6 Could this be our answer for TR6 rear brakes? Triumph 24
G NEED A QUICK ANSWER...setting drive dog for dizzy Triumph 8
JPSmit I think I know the answer but - dashboard question Spridgets 7
Team_Sprite Looking for a part and an answer to a "how to" Spridgets 13
G Still Learning, please answer a few questions? MG 1
jlaird Question that you all know the answer to Spridgets 8
jlaird Question, and I know the answer. Spridgets 5
zimmy cltack answer Spridgets 9
timbn2 Definitive Answer on Media Blasting, Please... Austin Healey 10
John Loftus Hey Patton - pitted chrome answer Austin Healey 2
S quick answer needed Spridgets 3
S Wedge The TR7 Temp issue -- finally, an answer Triumph 14
B Brake Fluid. The Wrong Answer. Restoration & Tools 10
Basil Question for Jeb...[or anyone who can answer] MG 1
jehuie Where to post for parts that fit many cars? FORUM Navigation Questions 1
Pythias Where to post FOR SALE Spridgets 1
PatPink TR6 Hello, I am new to the site and want to post some photos of my 1973 TR 6. I have done all mods to this car except body and paint. Triumph 10
P TR2/3/3A Block treatment post cleaning Triumph 17
jlaird MGB Don't post like I did 10 years ago. MG 7
EWD TR6 74 TR6 - “ A Post Seal” Triumph 0
jlaird MGB Follow up to my bad post on prewar MGs MG 4
Gliderman8 Editing a post FORUM Navigation Questions 6
F General Tech trouble with editing post Triumph 2
Michael Oritt Post- Open Roads 2002: Tahoe to MD the long way Austin Healey 19
S TR2/3/3A Stubborn door hinge screws in “A” Post Triumph 6
B TR6 New Member, first post Triumph 1
S TR4/4A B post to sill Triumph 5
Jim_Gruber Help and Advice needed for post pressure washing debacle Spridgets 10
Jim_Stevens For Sale Post-60K LH door Triumph Classifieds 2
R General Tech How to attach pic's to a post? Triumph 1
R Adding attachments to your Post FORUM Navigation Questions 1
tahoe healey past post about sholder belt foam Austin Healey 2
TomMull Elan Plus 2 post 1968 numbers don't quite match Lotus 0
H Windshield Post to Body - Captive nut needs to be replaced - Pillar to Body Spridgets 2
D Test image post FORUM Navigation Questions 1
ckeithjordan TR2/3/3A Apple Hydraulics vs White Post Restoration Triumph 13
M battery helmet stuck on post help Austin Healey 8
T Trouble inserting pictures to post FORUM Navigation Questions 2

Similar threads

Top