• Hi Guest! Being a Paying Supporter is NOT a requirement to participate at BCF. However, subscribing will help ensure we can continue to serve the LBC community for years to come. If you enjoy BCF and find our forum a useful resource...Please consider supporting us by **Upgrading**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this banner)
Tips
Tips

TR4/4A TR3 vs early TR4

mrv8q

Luke Skywalker
Country flag
Offline
For those of you in the know, how do you compare the driving experience between these two. Besides the upsized engine, R&P steering, and non side-screen aspect, how different are they? And by early TR4, I'm thinking 62-63...
 

Geo Hahn

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
mrv8q said:
...Besides the upsized engine, R&P steering, and non side-screen aspect, how different are they?...

Not much, but those are some pretty noticeable differences you mention.

The boot is shaped differently but I can't say that the TR4 really holds more.

Same seats.

Can lock the cubby box (but never do).

Dash support (on the 4) is somewhat intrusive on leg room.

Much easier to get the radiator out of a TR4.

Front sidelamps on the TR4 are pretty lame.

The 4 has a slightly wider track.

Cardboard for a gearbox tunnel? Would like to meet the guy who thought that was a great idea.

No drain plug on the diff of a 4 -- not too handy.

TR3 top -- up in minutes. TR4 top -- requires a building permit in some cities.

Both great cars -- hope I never have to choose which I like best.
 
OP
mrv8q

mrv8q

Luke Skywalker
Country flag
Offline
Ah, Geo, I might be able to emulate you one day, if you know what I mean...
 

tdskip

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
So keep in mind this is based on two crappy cars - mine of course, and one of them being a TR4A solid axle - but I found them to drive differently enough to be surprising. The 4A feels and drives, to me anyway, more substantial and modern. Steering, configuration of the interior and having regular doors all make for a very different experience. You thoughts based on cars in better condition may be different. (my 3a was pretty knackered when I got her, and drove like it)

Kevin - give me, oh, say 6 months and then you can do a comparison first hand.
 

TR6oldtimer

Darth Vader
Offline
One was a roadster, the other a convertible.

Once upon a time, a friend had a TR3B, I had an early TR4. We each drove the other's car. In the end, we both agreed the TR4 was a better handling and driving experience car. (It might be because mine did have 5.5" rims and Dunlop radial 190's)

Then again, this test was done in up state NY in late fall, so weather may had a lot to do with it.

Oh, by the way, he sold 3B before the snow came.
 

MGA75002

Member
Offline
Kevin, in a way, they are apples and oranges, in other ways, they are the same car. I had a 1958 TR3A the same time my girlfriend had an early TR4. This was in 1966.

Performance is the same: they have the same crappy steering and rear suspension. The 4 has slightly more hp, but it is a little heavier. So, performance is a wash. "Sportiness" is a different kettle of fish: with the low doors and smaller "feel" to the car, it was no contest. The 3 was a true sportscar for us oldtimers, whereas the roll-up windows were heresy. As an eye-catcher, the 3 had it over the 4, also. I can't comment on the "ride feel," as it was so long ago and my butt was 50 years younger; but, neither of them rode like a Rolls Royce, but we did not expect them to.

Now, for driving convenience, mah jongg! No contest. In top-up weather, there was ALWAYS something coming up where you were thankful you had the roll-up windows, whether a squall, a dust storm, a farmer spraying something, a swarm of mosquitos, something dead, et al. The sidecurtains are in the trunk, and, by the time you stop and get them installed, ...

We didn't have the trouble with the 4's convertible top that one observer had, probably just dumb luck on my GF's part. Her top was much easier to install than my 3 top.

Note: I just bought a TR3B. It has the 87mm pistons, and I can tell that it is alot peppier than my TR3A and her TR4 were. A lot peppier. I seem to be faster on the take off than most of the TR6s in our club, but, of course, they will leave me top-end, when their 150(?) hp kicks in. I wish I had OD.
 

BRSLimited

Jedi Trainee
Offline
They had the same basic frame with some minor changes, but the 4 was a heavier car with not much more power. The biggest thing in handling was a little wider tires and the change to rack and pinion steering.
 

M_Pied_Lourd

Darth Vader
Country flag
Offline
mga,

You might be ok...N/A (carb) TR6's were only 104 hp....now PI cars, might have your hands full....

Cheers,
M. Pied Lourd
 

Andrew Mace

Moderator
Staff member
Country flag
Offline
BRSLimited said:
They had the same basic frame with some minor changes, but the 4 was a heavier car with not much more power. The biggest thing in handling was a little wider tires and the change to rack and pinion steering.
Tires and wheels didn't change between the two, but the TR4 did have a wider track both front and rear, in addition to the R&P steering.

Personally, I feel that the comparison is between apples and...well...another variety of apples. :wink:
 

glemon

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
They both have a rear end that will be skittish around a bumpy corner, I think you feel closer to the ground in a 3 just because of the cut down doors, the different shape of the cars makes as much a difference as anything I think, there is much more of you exposed to the elements in a 3, you are pretty relatively well covered up on the 4.

Of course if it is more than just a fair wheather car the 4 has the better top and side windows. But most people arent't buying these cars as daily drivers anymore.

I have not owned a 3, but many drives as a passenger and a few as driver in my brothers 3 over the last 20 years or so he has had it, plus used to have a solid axle 4a, good buddy has a 4.
 
OP
mrv8q

mrv8q

Luke Skywalker
Country flag
Offline
Good replies, gentlemen, thanks!
 

MGA75002

Member
Offline
Right, MPL. Right after I posted, I realized that I was wrong on the TR6 hp, although I thought it was alot higher than 104. BTW, we have a TR4 with a Judson on it, and he can blow my doors off !!!

One last interesting fact about performance: per Bill Piggott's last book, the original TR2 was faster on acceleration than the TR7.

tr3bGeorge - my temporary room mate - told me that he didn't run into any of you at the two ABCDs he recently attended, but he met a swell crowd in the Texas Mini Owners group. He feels that he is going to place better in future shows, as he now has a picnic basket.

Philthy
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
A TR2/3/3A Early TR3 starter (bomb style) bushings sizes Triumph 2
S TR2/3/3A shifting tower shifting rods on an early tr3 tower Triumph 11
S TR2/3/3A how to install a gas tank in an early tr3 Triumph 8
R For Sale 1956 Early small mouth TR3 Triumph Classifieds 1
R TR2/3/3A Early TR3 electrical system Triumph 12
jfarris TR2/3/3A Uh Oh - will these carbs work on an early TR3 Triumph 4
jfarris TR2/3/3A Installing replica Brooklands Areoscreens on early TR3 Triumph 4
jfarris TR2/3/3A Early 56 TR3 H6 Carbs, distributor vacuum advance/retard Triumph 3
C TR2/3/3A Where to buy front calipers for an early[57] TR3? Triumph 7
K TR2/3/3A TR2 early TR3 windscreen stanchions Triumph 1
M TR2/3/3A ?????Early TR3 door fitting problem ????? Triumph 22
M TR2/3/3A Which frame is correct for early TR3 Triumph 18
M TR2/3/3A Who sells seal for early TR3 hardtop? Triumph 6
Marvin Gruber TR2/3/3A Early TR3 wire wheel set up. Triumph 9
T TR2/3/3A Early TR3/4 trans help needed Triumph 7
M TR2/3/3A Rebuild early bomb style starter TR3 Triumph 3
T TR2/3/3A Should there be a body ground strap to battery on TR3 Triumph 4
G For Sale: New Rear Window for TR2 TR3 TR3A TR3B HardTop Triumph Classifieds 0
G For Sale: Triumph TR2, TR3, TR3A Sheet Metal Body Parts – Front Apron (valence) with grille, Bonnet (hood), Doors, Boot (trunk) Deck Lid Triumph Classifieds 0
G For Sale: Triumph TR2, TR3, TR3A, TR3B Factory Steel Hardtop, New Rear window, Partial Bracket Set Triumph Classifieds 0
T TR2 - TR3 Gas Cap for sale Triumph Classifieds 0
B TR2/3/3A TR3 Hard Top Triumph 2
D TR2/3/3A TR3 throttle linkage bell crank. Triumph 13
M TR2/3/3A Defective master cylinders Tr3 Triumph 13
BarryO TR2/3/3A setting up a TR3 clutch slave Triumph 5
M master cylinder brake/clutch Tr3 Triumph Classifieds 6
C TR2/3/3A TR3 Gearbox Problem Triumph 10
Tr3aguy TR2/3/3A Started a Car revival channel for the TR3 Triumph 7
J TR2/3/3A Any advice for new floor install on my TR3? Triumph 9
D 1957 Triumph Tr3 Triumph Classifieds 2
P TR2/3/3A tr3 side curtains Triumph 4
banjojambo Triumph tr3 vertical link wobble Triumph 2
S TR2/3/3A purchased a box of tr3 parts this weekend, Triumph 1
C TR2/3/3A TR3 close by Triumph 2
D TR2/3/3A Tr3 horn testing and wiring Triumph 8
J For Sale Triumph TR2 TR3 TR3A New Moss Motors Black Karvel Style Carpet Kit Triumph Classifieds 0
B TR2/3/3A TR3 sag to the left [port sag] Triumph 10
K For Sale Triumph TR3 Bullnose Starter Triumph Classifieds 0
K For Sale TR3 rear rebound brackets Triumph Classifieds 0
K For Sale TR3 Radiator Guard Triumph Classifieds 0
S TR2/3/3A TR3 has me stumped, it runs then dies over and over and the exhaust system was pulled Triumph 9
D TR2/3/3A TR3 Headlamp Rings Triumph 8
O For Sale New Member from NJ 1960 TR3 Triumph Classifieds 1
K For Sale Rare TR3 Folding Lug Wrench Triumph Classifieds 1
A TR2/3/3A TR3-A replacement top Triumph 7
ckeithjordan TR2/3/3A TR3 Bulkhead Carpet Triumph 9
boxofparts TR2/3/3A TR3 Spotted Petoskey Michigan Red and Wedgewood or Powder Blue Triumph 1
L TR2/3/3A Any trick to removing TR3 doors? Triumph 12
K TR2/3/3A Non Adjustable TR3 Steering Wheel Triumph 2
L TR2/3/3A Who's using what to treat rusty stuff TR3 Triumph 7

Similar threads

Top