• The Roadster Factory Recovery Fund - Friends, as you may have heard, The Roadster Factory, a respected British Car Parts business in PA, suffered a total loss in a fire on Christmas Day. Read about it, discuss or ask questions >> HERE. The Triumph Register of America is sponsoring a fund raiser to help TRF get back on their feet. If you can help, vist >> their GoFundMe page.
  • Hey there Guest!
    If you enjoy BCF and find our forum a useful resource, if you appreciate not having ads pop up all over the place and you want to ensure we can stay online - Please consider supporting with an "optional" low-cost annual subscription.
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this UGLY banner)
Tips
Tips

Lightened flywheel options

DerekJ

Luke Skywalker
Country flag
Offline
I have been running my car in sprints and hillclimbs and this winter Im considering various upgrades I might make. One is to lighten the flywheel as quicker acceleration will suit the hills I'm running on.

I think my car still has the original flywheel. It has a BJ8 engine, with forged pistons, a DWR8 fast road cam and B&M Super Damper.

What is the weight of the original flywheel and what suggestions would people have regarding how much lighter I should go, - bearing in mind that I drive the car to the evnts so I need it to be driveable.
 

Bob_Spidell

Yoda
Gold
Country flag
Offline
My understanding--caveat: I don't have a lightened flywheel--is that the lighter flywheel won't do much if anything for the acceleration of the car (when you think about it, the flywheel is a very small part of the overall mass of the drivetrain and vehicle). The main advantage is a quicker-revving engine, good for quick blips of the throttle; e.g. to facilitate downshifts. At least, that's how an experienced racer explained it to me.
 

BoyRacer

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
I am an experienced racer. A lightened flywheel will make a huge difference! A BJ8 flywheel is about 28 pounds. Taking 6 pounds of weight off the flywheel will allow the engine to spin up much faster and there will be a noticeable improvement. It will feel as if you have more horsepower. The car WILL accelerate at at a much faster rate.
The most important place to remove weight is at the outer diameter of the flywheel. This is more important than simply removing weight. You can achieve even more weight reduction by scalloping out material between the mounting holes for the clutch.
 

Bob_Spidell

Yoda
Gold
Country flag
Offline
I defer to Richard with his actual experience. Still, it doesn't make sense to me since the weight removed is negligible compared to the overall mass of the car. I just can't see the physics involved. Removing weight from the car, aerodynamic mods, less unsprung weight, etc. make sense, but removing a small bit of the rotating mass wouldn't seem to make much difference, except for faster (unloaded) revving.

Anyone have before/after dyno numbers with just flywheel lightening? Track times? Hill climb numbers?
 
Country flag
Offline
Bob, this was how it made sense to me...

Tie a nut on a piece of string; hold the string about a foot away from the end and spin the nut around, noting the "speed" at which the nut makes a revolution.

With your other hand, pull the string so that now there's only about 6" of string length and note how much faster the nut is spinning.

When cutting a flywheel, the object is to remove the most (excess) mass from the outer circumference, freeing it up to spin faster. The flywheel in my car was cut decades ago, and yes, it really makes a difference.

IMG_7663.jpg


IMG_7664.jpg


IMG_7665.jpg


IMG_7666.jpg
 
Country flag
Offline
Oh, and another little bonus benefit, is that the car will also decelerate faster too; lift your foot off the gas and the speed drops noticably faster__great for autocross type events.

The really uncanny part is when you switch the engine off__immediate silence.
 
OP
DerekJ

DerekJ

Luke Skywalker
Country flag
Offline
Thanks guys, great information, just what I was looking for.

Randy, good point re the cut off - I guess that will also help eliminate the run-on that I have from time to time

...and Randy... you have a photograph of absolutely everything! Brilliant.

Bob,

The reason for the improvement is that a fly wheel is really a device to store energy, and it also smooths out an internal combustion engine. In a performance engine you don't care about the smoothing and so with a lighter flywheel energy is freed to directly power the car rather than be stored in the flywheel.
 
Country flag
Offline
It's more of the same with road wheels too; racers want the lightest combination possible, to reduce the amount of rotational mass they need to accelerate.

Guys that put those humongous wheels on a car might as well be tying an anchor to the rear bumper!
 

Bob_Spidell

Yoda
Gold
Country flag
Offline
Between Randy's and Richard's comments I'm convinced a lightened flywheel improves performance, but I'm still confused about the physics. The mass of the car is about 2,400 lbs. Assume that the engine makes, oh, 100lb-ft of torque off-idle. All the gear reduction--roughly 4:1 in the gearbox and 4:1 in the rear-end gives about 16 times 'amplification' of torque. A little slipping of the clutch to get the car moving and the combined engine torque and gear reduction is adequate to start moving the car forward, and as momentum is increased less torque--hence higher gearing--is desired.

The analogy I thought of is this: imagine a Healey engine on a stand turning a large, heavy wheel; i.e. a huge flywheel. With the weight and resistance of the flywheel, clutch and gearbox factored in a large wheel weighing--I'm just guessing here--about 1,600 or so pounds might be equivalent to the mass of a Big Healey. I just can't understand how removing 6lb or so would make a huge difference (but two of the most knowledgeable people on the forum say it does). What I do understand is if the 1,600 lb. wheel is, say, 10 feet in diameter removing 6lb from the periphery would make a difference, but if the wheel is thick but small diameter--say 3ft.--removing 6lb from the periphery wouldn't be much difference (the 'string theory').

I'm still looking for hard data; i.e. 'my track/quarter-mile times improved 3% after I had my flywheel lightened.' I don't think you'll see any difference on a dyno, unless there is an actual increase in rate of acceleration and the dyno can compute that.

The large, heavy road wheels I understand, as you're looking and maybe 10-20lbs. times 4 at the outside of almost 30in. of diameter.

While we're talking physics, can anyone explain why 'unsprung' weight is worse than, well, sprung weight?
 

Patrick67BJ8

Obi Wan
Silver
Country flag
Offline
DerekJ said:
Thanks guys, great information, just what I was looking for.

Randy, good point re the cut off - I guess that will also help eliminate the run-on that I have from time to time

...and Randy... you have a photograph of absolutely everything! Brilliant.

Bob,

The reason for the improvement is that a fly wheel is really a device to store energy, and it also smooths out an internal combustion engine. In a performance engine you don't care about the smoothing and so with a lighter flywheel energy is freed to directly power the car rather than be stored in the flywheel.
I submitted and magazine article from the early years showing how much to lighten the flywheel, https://www.healey6.com/Technical/Competition.pdf ,(John Simm's website). The article is very informative on getting more horses from the "6".
 

Bob_Spidell

Yoda
Gold
Country flag
Offline
Thanks. I'm convinced. That's the kind of 'proof' I was looking for. In short, lightening the flywheels is effectively equivalent to lightening the car, and I can understand how that increases performance (esp. acceleration). For me, lightening the flywheel might offset slower acceleration due to the taller (3.54:1) rearend in my BJ8.

Can anyone explain why 'unsprung' weight is bad (I suspect the logic/math is similar to the flywheel explanation)?
 

HealeyRick

Yoda
Silver
Country flag
Offline
DerekJ said:
Here is another good article that explains the pros and cons. Overall there is no real increase in 'power'. The difference is in how it is delivered. Lightened flywheels are recommended for motorsport use.

https://chicaneculture.com/2010/05/basics-flywheel/

Careful, my Avast anti virus just blocked a trojan horse from that webpage
 

roscoe

Jedi Knight
Silver
Country flag
Offline
Another way to look at it (and I'm sorry I didn't take the time to read the referenced articles, maybe this week-end), is that all engines develop their rated power at their rated "higher" rpms. If you have a 90 HP motor it ain't going to put that out at 1000 rpm unless it has humongous pistons and displacement. So it makes sense to me that if it spins up faster it can deliver power faster, regardless of the fact that the overall mass of the car doesn't really change much. You will wear out your clutch faster, it will not be as smooth as previously noted.
 
OP
DerekJ

DerekJ

Luke Skywalker
Country flag
Offline
Horse power is Torque (ft/lbs) x Revolutions / 5252.

When an engine is quoted as producing 200 hp that is at or close to its maximum revs. That is the only time it produces 200hp. Less revs = less hp. That is why mid range torque is so important.
 

Genos2

Jedi Trainee
Offline
Derekj, food for thought, I used & ran a Dynojet dyno for years at a turbo shop. Many engines(most) quit making hp lomg before max rpms, some turbo cars will keep climbing w/enough fuel or boost. IMO & experience max revs doesn't equate to max hp, that's why cars were run on dyno to determine when to shift & what rpm,. Just commenting
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
T TR4/4A Flywheel... Lightened or Stock, that is the question Triumph 14
F TR4/4A Lightened Flywheel for TR3A/TR4 engine Triumph 12
rjc157 lightened flywheel Austin Healey 9
G Lightened 1500 Flywheel? Spridgets 4
davidk Lightened Stock Flywheel Triumph 26
6 Pics of Lightened Steel Flywheel Spridgets 5
cjm lightened flywheel,best fixing? Triumph 3
C WHO HAS A LIGHTENED FLYWHEEL - AH 3000 Austin Healey 2
P Crankshaft and Flywheel Lightened ?? Triumph 4
P Lightened Flywheel Austin Healey 10
Y MGB Flywheel saga continues.... MG 24
tr6nitjulius For Sale TR6 tail light assemby & Resurfaced/New Ring Gear Flywheel Triumph Classifieds 0
Y MGB Flywheel resurface? MG 2
KVH General Tech Flywheel Bolts Too Long For Main Seal Triumph 13
Michael Oritt 100 Flywheel Weight Austin Healey 16
BoyRacer 6 cylinder flywheel on a 100 engine? Austin Healey 0
WHT Denis Welch CENG635SO Flywheel Austin Healey 0
R For Sale Fidanza Aluminum Flywheel for 1275 A-Series Spridgets Classified 0
D 1.8 2007 Toyota Avensis Clutch & Flywheel Torque Settings? Other Cars 0
J BJ8 flywheel take some pounds off Austin Healey 17
roscoe Flywheel orientation question Austin Healey 3
R TR6 Pilot bushing clearance and Fidanza flywheel Triumph 0
AUSMHLY Shifting into 2nd, problem because of the Flywheel? Austin Healey 21
M TR2/3/3A What Flywheel is this? Triumph 3
J TR2/3/3A Flywheel-Crank Dowel Alignment Triumph 6
R Wanted BJ8 FlyWheel Austin Healey Classifieds 6
M TR2/3/3A Starter and Flywheel Combinations Triumph 2
Rut Crank/flywheel dowels Spridgets 3
JimLaney Flywheel Pitting Spridgets 4
S TR2/3/3A Alloy flywheel Triumph 13
K TR4/4A TR4A clutch pressure plate to flywheel bolt "torque value"? Triumph 2
TRopic6 For Sale Flywheel for TR250/'69 TR6 Triumph Classifieds 0
drooartz ID a 1275 flywheel Spridgets 2
D TR4/4A flywheel bolts maybe too long Triumph 15
trotti Flywheel removal Austin Healey 4
drooartz Looking for a 1275 flywheel Spridgets 17
A 1955 100/4 Flywheel Info Austin Healey 4
T Post-War Other Herald flywheel Triumph 3
B Clutch disc - which side goes towards flywheel? Austin Healey 8
abarth69 1275 Flywheel Wanted Spridgets 7
CJD TR2/3/3A Clutch/Flywheel Bolts Triumph 28
T TR2/3/3A How many guide holes in TR3 flywheel for crank pin? Triumph 2
J TR2/3/3A Flywheel bolts Triumph 1
DNK General Tech Flywheel Bolts Triumph 6
K TR6 Flywheel installed without the locating dowels? Triumph 5
K TR2/3/3A Lightening a stock TR3A flywheel..... Triumph 13
O TR2/3/3A TR4 Flywheel Triumph 4
toysrrus TR6 TR6 & GT6 Flywheel, Clutch question: Triumph 4
RedTR3 TR2/3/3A Moss [ARP] Flywheel Bolts Triumph 16
K TR2/3/3A Torque value for TR3 clutch cover to flywheel bolts....... Triumph 2

Similar threads

Top