• The Roadster Factory Recovery Fund - Friends, as you may have heard, The Roadster Factory, a respected British Car Parts business in PA, suffered a total loss in a fire on Christmas Day. Read about it, discuss or ask questions >> HERE. The Triumph Register of America is sponsoring a fund raiser to help TRF get back on their feet. If you can help, vist >> their GoFundMe page.
  • Hey there Guest!
    If you enjoy BCF and find our forum a useful resource, if you appreciate not having ads pop up all over the place and you want to ensure we can stay online - Please consider supporting with an "optional" low-cost annual subscription.
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this UGLY banner)
Tips
Tips

TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Noise

Vince

Member
Offline
I am struggling to figure out root cause on a slight tapping noise on my TR3A. The engine had not been run for over 30 years until last year. It has great compression and oil pressure, runs very strong. But under load, at about 2500 rpm and higher, it makes a slight tapping noise. You can make the sound come/go purely with throttle position while driving. We were able to re-create the sound while sitting still if you rev the engine quickly, it will make the sound as it ramps up in rpm. Then a friend listened with stethoscope, determined it was cylinder #3, we unplugged that cylinder and the tap went away. Thought maybe it was excessive carbon buildup, looked like a lot of carbon thru the plug hole. Tried Sea Foam spray in plug hole, soaked overnight, then sprayed through carbs - lots of smoke but when done it still makes the slight tapping noise.

Have already made mixture richer, checked timing, and switched to 92 octane fuel. None of these seem to really make a difference. Rocker clearances all look fine.

Any other ideas?
 

M_Pied_Lourd

Darth Vader
Country flag
Offline
Timing Chain?

Cheers,
M. Pied Lourd
 

NutmegCT

Great Pumpkin
Gold
Offline
Vince - if it's a *slight* tapping noise, which changes with rpm, I think it's perfectly normal.

Many guys here report something similar - which is just how the valves sound when normal.

Anyway, mine has the slight tapping noise; has had it since new. At first I worried; then a long-time TR owner said it's the way it's supposed to sound.

Tom
 

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
The "normal" noises are from the valve train, and don't change with throttle position. They also aren't specific to one cylinder (although a bad rocker or valve might be). Since Vince's noise does change with throttle position, it has to be something that "sees" engine load.

My guess from the description would be piston slap, or (more likely) a loose wrist pin (aka gudgeon pin). Might not be anything to worry about, but if it starts getting louder, those are the things I would look at.

It's not a lot of fun to pull a rod out on a 3A, but at least it can be done without removing the engine or front apron.
 

BillyB62

Jedi Trainee
Country flag
Offline
Thanks Tom, I pulled my car out of the garage this weekend (winter is almost over in New England, although it never really came) and ran it for a little bit. I just bought the car over the winter and I'm readying it for registration. The slight tapping concerned me but to hear it is normal is comforting. I'll let some of the other local TR3 owners in the state listen when I begin going to shows .
 

bgbassplyr

Darth Vader
Offline
Randall beat me to it,but I agree with him.....wrist pin.....or piston slap.
 

TimK1955tr2

Senior Member
Offline
Last summer I had a loud tapping/clacking sound that appeared like it was coming the top end/valve train, it sounded very serious.

But it was just the Woodruff key that mounts the water pump pulley to its shaft being badly worn, allowing the pulley to tap against the housing or pump mounting bolts. I was able to rock the pulley on the shaft with the engine off but didn't notice any movement with the engine running.

Installing new key (found at sears), solved the problem and noise.

Kind of a long shot but worth a look... good luck!!
 
OP
V

Vince

Member
Offline
John, the exhaust leak occurred to me too recently. Seems to line up better with the symptoms. Any ideas on how to confirm? Of course, it's not that hard to replace the manifold gasket......
 

EV2239

Jedi Warrior
Offline
It could be a big end or crank problem because both will make a noise as you describe.

Oil pressure should be 70 at 2000 rpm and tick over at over thirty.

I'd drop the sump and have a look at the state of the journals.
 

CJD

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
I wish I could say I have a good trick to tell a leak, but I really don't. Normally you can run your hand around to feel it blowing, but that's not very easy with the exhaust and intake in the same plane on the TR3!?! An exhaust leak is always sharper, or more piercing, sounding when the engine is cold. It also tends to go away when the engine is not under load. The only thing I can add is that it would be very obvious once you pull the gasket, and it's much easier than pulling heads, pans, or rods.


John
 

NutmegCT

Great Pumpkin
Gold
Offline
Vince - just a suggestion ...

Could you make a short audio and/or video so we can actually hear that sound? Maybe upload it to YouTube?

If you need help in doing that, just let us know.

Thanks.
Tom
 

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
Vince said:
Any ideas on how to confirm?
Pour something into the intake that causes lots of exhaust smoke, like Casite or Rislone. Even ATF would probably do. Be careful though, don't want to pour in too much! Then look for any wisps of smoke coming away from the exhaust manifold area.
 
OP
V

Vince

Member
Offline
Today I went to a friend's house and we adjusted the timing, ended up removing about 95% of the sound. So I believe it was detonation. Still curious why it seems to dominant on cylinder #3. But the engine seems to run fine with the timing retarded back.

I also found out when I replaced the timing chain and tensioner I put the lower pulley back on wrong, apparently. The timing mark on the pulley is off 180 degrees. But if you put your timing light on cylinder #3 then you can set the timing just fine.

Btw, my older manuals don't give good data on where to set the timing when using a light, and with my conversion to Pertronix I can't do the 12 volt bulb thing. We set it about 2 degrees before TDC (about 1/8 inch from mark), was at about 12 degrees when detonating (about 5/8 inch). Does anyone know where the timing "should" be with a timing light? Not that I'll change it because it seems to be running pretty darn good now.

Vince
 

Geo Hahn

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
Vince said:
... if you put your timing light on cylinder #3 then you can set the timing just fine...

That should have some future owner saying a few choice words about you.

I have never used Pertonix but one way to set timing with a light it to set total timing (high RPM) where you want it and let idle timing be whatever it is.
 
D

Deleted member 29929

Guest
Guest
Offline
Today I went to a friend's house and we adjusted the timing, ended up removing about 95% of the sound. So I believe it was detonation. Still curious why it seems to dominant on cylinder #3. But the engine seems to run fine with the timing retarded back.

I also found out when I replaced the timing chain and tensioner I put the lower pulley back on wrong, apparently. The timing mark on the pulley is off 180 degrees. But if you put your timing light on cylinder #3 then you can set the timing just fine.

Btw, my older manuals don't give good data on where to set the timing when using a light, and with my conversion to Pertronix I can't do the 12 volt bulb thing. We set it about 2 degrees before TDC (about 1/8 inch from mark), was at about 12 degrees when detonating (about 5/8 inch). Does anyone know where the timing "should" be with a timing light? Not that I'll change it because it seems to be running pretty darn good now.

Vince
Unbelievable that you don’t know you shouldn’t use a timing light on a TR2 / 3 / 3A / 4 or 4A. These engines are designed to be statically timed @ 4 degrees. No timing light is required or effective. Simply find top dead centre (tdc) and turn the knurled knob … half a turn from memory. Unbelievable that other contributors haven’t jumped in and advised you this. It’s something specific to this engine - ex Massey Ferguson tractor and prior to that, a Water Pump based engine.
 

Mickey Richaud

Moderator
Staff member
Gold
Country flag
Offline
Unbelievable that you don’t know you shouldn’t use a timing light on a TR2 / 3 / 3A / 4 or 4A. These engines are designed to be statically timed @ 4 degrees. No timing light is required or effective. Simply find top dead centre (tdc) and turn the knurled knob … half a turn from memory. Unbelievable that other contributors haven’t jumped in and advised you this. It’s something specific to this engine - ex Massey Ferguson tractor and prior to that, a Water Pump based engine.
Never heard of not using a timing light on any multi-cylinder internal combustion engine, regardless of make.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
T TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Noise trouble. New to Triumphs. Granfather's Car. Need Help. Triumph 43
MGTF1250Dave TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Noise Identified Triumph 11
MGTF1250Dave TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Noise Up-date Triumph 11
MGTF1250Dave TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Noise Triumph 26
J TR2/3/3A TR3 engine cylinder top clearance Triumph 22
Pool Dad 1960 TR3 engine serial number Triumph 14
Joel Lester TR2/3/3A "TR3" painted on the engine block Triumph 13
K For Sale TR3 Engine Lift Bracket...hard to find! Triumph Classifieds 0
HalLucy Standard Vanguard Sportsman engine and the TR3 Other British Cars 7
Got_All_4 TR2/3/3A TR3 engine hand crank Triumph 14
Moosca TR2/3/3A "56 TR3 Engine Verification Triumph 17
D TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine dumping Coolant out its rear end - HELP Triumph 5
W TR2/3/3A Novice TR3 Engine Rebuild Triumph 47
J TR2/3/3A TR3 engine build Triumph 12
doc50 TR2/3/3A How to verify TR3 engine numbers Triumph 20
6 TR2/3/3A Engine in my TR3 Triumph 15
M TR2/3/3A TR3 engine hood wanted Triumph 7
Kleykamp TR2/3/3A TR3 lower engine parts?? Triumph 2
Got_All_4 TR2/3/3A Tr3 engine trany pull Triumph 6
Brinkerhoff TR2/3/3A TR3 free engine parts to forum members Triumph 6
K TR2/3/3A Putting an XKE engine in a TR3? Triumph 10
Kleykamp TR2/3/3A TR4 engine into TR3 crankcase vent tube? Triumph 16
RedTR3 TR2/3/3A Tips for Breaking in a Rebuilt TR3 Engine Triumph 6
charleyf TR2/3/3A tr6 OD tranny on a TR3 engine Triumph 7
DornTRoriginal TR2/3/3A Timing Chain Installation Procedures [TR3 engine TS 36161E] Triumph 5
mt10flyer TR2/3/3A 1959 TR3 engine rebuild problems Triumph 14
PatGalvin TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Front Sealing Block, Oil Pan Screw Size and Thread Pitch? Triumph 11
T TR2/3/3A having no shame I ask another question about a TR3 engine that is giving me fits Triumph 10
DornTRoriginal TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Painting Triumph 8
5 TR2/3/3A TR3 engine building tips needed Triumph 5
AEW TR2/3/3A TR3 engine front cover repair Triumph 10
D TR2/3/3A tr3 engine Triumph 6
H TR2/3/3A Cant get my Tr3 engine to start. any advice? Triumph 29
NutmegCT TR2/3/3A TR3 engine question Triumph 6
MGTF1250Dave TR2/3/3A Questions about Breaking in a refreshed TR3 Engine Triumph 13
MGTF1250Dave TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Rebuilt & Installed Triumph 7
O TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Miss Part 2 Triumph 11
O TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Miss Triumph 5
K TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine block marking? Triumph 4
G TR2/3/3A TR3 Rear engine seal issue Triumph 13
T TR2/3/3A TR3 engine ground Triumph 9
O TR2/3/3A TR3 engine removal Triumph 5
Bremer TR2/3/3A Hypothetical: Big bore TR3/4 engine Triumph 13
PatGalvin TR2/3/3A Engine Harness and/or Attachment Points for TR3 Triumph 10
C TR2/3/3A tr3 engine numbers Triumph 23
MGTF1250Dave TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Hoisting Fittings Triumph 5
T TR2/3/3A TR3 floor replacement. Engine in or out? Triumph 3
K TR2/3/3A TR3@70mph engine seemed to "flatten out" or..... Triumph 10
A TR2/3/3A TR3 engine removal Triumph 9
GBRandy TR2/3/3A TR3 Engine Bay Color Triumph 5

Similar threads

Top