• The Roadster Factory Recovery Fund - Friends, as you may have heard, The Roadster Factory, a respected British Car Parts business in PA, suffered a total loss in a fire on Christmas Day. Read about it, discuss or ask questions >> HERE. The Triumph Register of America is sponsoring a fund raiser to help TRF get back on their feet. If you can help, vist >> their GoFundMe page.
  • Hey there Guest!
    If you enjoy BCF and find our forum a useful resource, if you appreciate not having ads pop up all over the place and you want to ensure we can stay online - Please consider supporting with an "optional" low-cost annual subscription.
    **Upgrade Now**
    (PS: Subscribers don't see this UGLY banner)
Tips
Tips

TR4/4A New pinion seal doesn't fit!

Sarastro

Obi Wan
Silver
Country flag
Offline
Just finishing the restoration of my differential. Started to install the pinion seal, and found that there is no way on earth it will fit. I bought it from TRF. The car is a solid-axle TR4A.

The seal's OD is 2.690 inches, and the opening at the front of the differential, where it has to fit, is 2.620. The old, original seal that I removed was 2.625 OD, which makes sense. I can't see any way this new one will go in, but maybe there is. If so, could someone enlighten me? What have you guys used?

I did a little research, and found that the seal no. 470487N is the one listed everywhere for the TR4, and I also found the dimensions in a Timken catalog (below). The TRF seal has those dimensions. It appears that the 451857 should fit; it's nitrile instead of polyacrylate, and there are small differences in the style of the seal. I don't think those differences are significant, so lacking any other suggestions, I think I'll get one of those.
 

Attachments

  • seals.jpg
    seals.jpg
    70.3 KB · Views: 162

malbaby

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
Assuming that you still have your old seal, why not take it to your local bearing shop and have them replace it.
 

poolboy

Yoda
Country flag
Online
Is the outer rim of the old seal still stuck in the case ?
 
OP
Sarastro

Sarastro

Obi Wan
Silver
Country flag
Offline
No, the case is quite empty, no bits of seal left. I took out the old seal, which appears to be original--it is one of the leather ones. I'm sure that, if I took it to a seal shop, it would be a real conversation piece. I suppose I should just get one of the 451857s, but it would be nice to know what's going on. I can't believe I'm the first person to notice this.

I've noticed that the 470487 is listed for TR3s and TR4s as well, so the problem doesn't appear to be that it's only for IRS cars.
 

sp53

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
Well order the other one and compare. I remember the last one I put in was tight and I used some of that aviation gasket sealer for grease ( had to work kinda quickly but that stuff stays runny for a while) to help it slid in plus I had to smack it kind of hard, but it went-- plus I had to work it in a little with a block of wood and a slightly large hammer.
sp
 

titanic

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
It looks like you received a seal for the IRS diff. I measured the seal from a TR6 (same as the IRS TR4A) and it is 2.680".
Berry
 
OP
Sarastro

Sarastro

Obi Wan
Silver
Country flag
Offline
Thanks. I kinda thought that might be the case, but I don't have an IRS car near me to see. the seal I bought is specifically listed in the TRF catalog as being for the solid-axle TR4As. I've exchanged a few emails with their customer service, emphatically recommending that they change the catalog. They promised to send me one of the seals for the earlier cars. Also, I bought a 451857, which arrived yesterday. I'll compare it to the new one I get from TRF, then post the results--and also let the people at TRF know.
 
OP
Sarastro

Sarastro

Obi Wan
Silver
Country flag
Offline
Just a follow-up: I went ahead and installed the 451857. It fits perfectly.

TRF is sending me another seal, a different part no. It's listed for some of the earlier solid-axle cars; I'll bet it is actually a 451857. I should receive it in a few days. We'll see.
 

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
According to the parts catalogs, solid axle 4A should take the same seal as IRS; which is different than the earlier solid axle.
Is there any chance that what you have is actually an earlier axle, possibly with the bracket for the bump stop added?
 

titanic

Jedi Warrior
Country flag
Offline
Moss and BPNW list different numbers for the solid axle and IRS diffs (520-100 for IRS and 520-090 for solid axle) pinion seals. In the infamous words of Henry Lee, "Something not right here"
Berry
According to the parts catalogs, solid axle 4A should take the same seal as IRS; which is different than the earlier solid axle.
Is there any chance that what you have is actually an earlier axle, possibly with the bracket for the bump stop added?
 

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
Just for grins, here are the listings from the factory SPC (2nd edition in both cases). First TR4A, then TR4
TR4A IRS.JPG

TR4A solid axle.JPG


TR4 pinion seal.jpg
 
OP
Sarastro

Sarastro

Obi Wan
Silver
Country flag
Offline
Hmmmm....the plot thickens.

In a 50-year-old car, anything is possible, but I don't see any indication that the axle has been replaced. The crud layer on it was much the same as the rest of the car, and all the bits, like the mounts and handbrake-cable supports, are like a 4A. Finally, this car appears to have been left alone and neglected for decades. I can't imagine someone who doesn't even care much about basic maintenance changing out a rear axle.

I received the seal from TRF yesterday, and it clearly would fit, but it's not the 451857. It is the one they sell for TR4s; their part no. is 100898. My best guess is that there is an error in the parts manual, and TRF and others used that info to stock their parts.
 

Tr4aJim

Senior Member
Offline
Steve,
This winter I am going to replace the pinion seal on my solid axle Tr4a. I was looking up the part on the Revington TR site, and they have this note listed with the part:

[FONT=&quot]The Original Triumph TR4A parts catalogue does not list the Axle Pinion Seal correctly in so far as seal 140337 is listed for both the independent suspension axle unit and the live axle unit. [/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]Seal 100898 is approximately 2mm smaller in outside dia than 140337 and fits the live axle.[/FONT]
[FONT=&quot]Seal 140337 fits the independent suspension axle[/FONT]


Jim
 
OP
Sarastro

Sarastro

Obi Wan
Silver
Country flag
Offline
Jim, that's interesting--I had missed it. But it confirms what I suspected.

In other news, I wrote back to the helpful customer service guy at TRF, thanked him again for sending the correct seal, and gave him the link to this thread.
 

TR3driver

Great Pumpkin - R.I.P
Offline
I stuck a note in the PDF I maintain ...
 

glemon

Yoda
Country flag
Offline
Not really adding much to the conversation I guess, but I have a fuzzy memory of the same thing happening to me with my TR4A solid axle. Probably close to 20 years ago or more. Don't remember the vendor, but I usually order from VB or TRF. But I guess that is consistent with the factory manual mistake on the part number.
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
A Spitfire Spitfire Diff Pinion Seal? Triumph 2
edkap2002 TR6 TR6 rear pinion seal Triumph 3
Joel Lester TR2/3/3A What size speedi-sleeve needed for pinion seal on a TR3? Triumph 6
luke44 TR2/3/3A TR3 pinion seal - leaked from sitting will it reseal? Triumph 12
N Pinion Seal Replacement Spridgets 2
D BT-7 pinion seal replacement Austin Healey 8
T TR4/4A Replacing rear pinion seal - remove driveshaft? Triumph 21
T Steering Box Pinion Seal [?] Spridgets 1
KVH General TR Pinion Seal Goof Up Triumph 3
Boink 3.9 diff and pinion seal Spridgets 2
drooartz Diff pinion seal Spridgets 8
Geo Hahn General TR Diff Pinion Seal Triumph 5
mcmillal TR4/4A Pinion Oil Seal Replacement Triumph 10
H Pinion seal PN Austin Healey 2
T TR2/3/3A 2 questions on diff front pinion seal replace-TR3A Triumph 7
HealeyRick Pinion Seal Questions Austin Healey 8
Willie_P Hibernation over...I'm back...Pinion Seal question Triumph 4
O TR6 TR6 Pinion Seal Triumph 4
Bremer TR2/3/3A TR3A pinion seal removal Triumph 8
bighealeysource Pinion shaft oil seal -Latest to oil leak Austin Healey 8
MGTF1250Dave TR2/3/3A TR3A Rear Axle Pinion Oil Seal Replacement Triumph 8
jvandyke pinion oil seal failure? Spridgets 2
71tr Part No. for Nissan R200 diff pinion seal Triumph 0
R MGB MGB pinion seal MG 2
CCURTISS Rear Axle Pinion Seal Triumph 7
rlandrum Bad Pinion Seal Triumph 4
S Pinion seal replacement Triumph 4
svtmikey Pinion Seal Replacement Triumph 1
prb51 TR2/3/3A TR3 Dif Pinion seal and speedy sleeve Triumph 12
MtnDriver Replacing Pinion Oil Seal MG 6
F MGB Pinion Oil Seal Replacement - MGB Tube Type Axel MG 8
D TR4/4A TR4 rear diff pinion seal Triumph 4
Westfield_XI Steering pinion oil seal Spridgets 11
G TR5/TR250 TR 250/early 6 rear pinion oil seal Triumph 0
prb51 TR2/3/3A 56 TR3 pinion seal Triumph 8
S Changing the Rear End Pinion Seal Triumph 3
Musicman R & R of Pinion Oil Seal Triumph 8
Musicman Possible Seeping Pinion Oil Seal Triumph 6
T Pinion seal replacement Spridgets 7
R TR2/3/3A TR3 rack and pinion kit problem... Triumph 12
S TR2/3/3A Pinion tail bearing replacing Triumph 12
M MGA RHD twin cam steering pinion MG 0
Scotsman Rack and Pinion Conversion for 3000 Austin Healey 7
M Need help removing the pinion assembly from a late 1275 steering rack Spridgets 7
T 3.54 Crown & Pinion Sources Austin Healey 13
M MGA RHD rack and pinion wanted MG 19
C For Sale New in box 3:54 ring & pinion Austin Healey Classifieds 4
T TR2/3/3A TR3A rack & pinion conversion question - solution for horn & directional lever Triumph 2
C TR2/3/3A Rack and Pinion Conversion for Tr's Triumph 0
M TR2/3/3A Speedy Sleeve Repair Sleeves for Rear Axle Pinion and Half Shafts Triumph 1

Similar threads

Top